Academic Thought · Expanded Edition
Scientific Computing Platform for Geophysical Geodesy · Systematic Exposition of the Academic Thought (Expanded Edition) · 2026

Reshaping Geodesy through the Earth's Gravity Field
— The Academic Thought and Paradigm Breakthroughs of the Scientific Computing Platform for Geophysical Geodesy

Drawing on the official website www.zcyphygeodesy.com and its “Ideas & Philosophy” section, the monograph pages of Physical Geodesy and Geodesy for a Deforming Earth, the function pages of PAGravf4.5 and ETideLoad4.5, the nine teaching courseware pages, the Fortran Codes section and the theoretical paper pages, this report systematically sets out the complete thread of the platform's academic thought, from the philosophical tenets and the disciplinary positioning through to the seven paradigm breakthroughs.

3 philosophical tenetsobjective uniqueness · precise measurability · spatiotemporal unity
7 paradigm breakthroughsthe framework given on the official monograph page
9 datum constantsexisting, and existing only, mutually independent
1 innovation closed looporiginal theory – rigorous algorithms – independent software – validation and application
G

Master Guideline: One Platform, One Body of Academic Thought, Four Turns

This report follows, item by item, the four-part structure given on the official page for the monograph Physical Geodesy.
Centred on the theory of the Earth's gravity field and grounded philosophically in “objective uniqueness, precise measurability and spatiotemporal unity”, this book expands Physical Geodesy from a companion branch of the geodetic discipline into a precise geodetic science that simultaneously addresses the Earth's figure, datum theory, geodetic synergy, Earth system analysis and mass-transport monitoring. It breaks the separated state of the gravity field, the reference frame, the height datum and relativity, and constructs a “four-in-one” theoretical system for the geodetic discipline, guiding geodetic education to strengthen the cultivation of “problem-driven” systems thinking and innovative capacity.— official page for Physical Geodesy (ZHANG Chuanyin, 2026, Chinese Science Press), /h-nd-164.html

G.1Composition of the Platform and Its Academic Positioning

The platform was independently developed over a decade by the team of Prof. ZHANG Chuanyin of the Chinese Academy of Surveying and Mapping, integrating more than twenty years of research results, and comprises two systems: the Precise Approximation of Earth Gravity Field and Geoid (PAGravf4.5) — a scientific computing package for geodesy grounded in steady-state gravity field theory, also referred to on the official site as the “gravity field engine” of this theoretical system — and the Earth Tide, Load Effect and Deformation Monitoring Computation (ETideLoad4.5) — a large Windows program package for scientific computing of geodetic monitoring, also referred to as the “deformation effect processor”. The platform and its core source codes have been open-sourced and made freely accessible since September 2021.

G.2The Official-Site Framework: Four Blocks of the Academic Thought

BlockContentCorresponding chapter in this report
I. Disciplinary philosophy and paradigm innovationThe revolutionary upgrade of the disciplinary positioning; reshaping the theoretical foundation of the geodetic discipline; the three philosophical tenets for upgrading the disciplinary system; the upgrades of the disciplinary philosophy and systemChapter 1
II. Paradigm breakthroughs and disruptive innovation in the core theories① The terrestrial reference frame: from “convention” to “determined by the gravity field”; ② the height datum: clarifying a century-old confusion; ③ relativistic geodesy: from an abstract conceptual theory to engineered algorithms; ④ all-element effect treatment: a unified, analytically compatible integration framework; ⑤ gravity field approximation methodology: collaborative inversion in the era of big space-air-land-sea data; ⑥ an integrated reference system for a deforming Earth; ⑦ streamlining theory and improving cognition: critical inheritance and strategic simplificationChapters 2–8
III. Support from an independent research platformThe complete innovation closed loop of “original theory – rigorous algorithms – independent software – validation and application”; the division of labour between PAGravf4.5 and ETideLoad4.5Chapters 9–11
IV. Summary and intended readershipSummary of the paradigm reconstruction and the audience it recommendsChapter 12
This four-part structure is taken verbatim from the “content summary” and the outline of the main text on official page h-nd-164.

G.3Four Keywords of the Master Guideline

KeywordMeaningOfficial-site basis
Optimizing the foundational logicBy highlighting geodetic principles, tenets and requirements, unnecessary complexity in theoretical methods is reduced, so that fundamental scientific problems can be effectively grasped and applied technical problems solvedOpening of the “Ideas & Philosophy” section, /h-col-105.html
Paradigm shift in cognitionFrom “technical data service” to “Earth system analysis”; and in education, from “technology-oriented” knowledge transfer to “problem-driven” systems thinking and conceptual innovationPlatform positioning paragraph of the official-site home page
The “four-in-one” cornerstoneTerrestrial reference frames, vertical datums and relativistic geodesy in Earth space are unified upon the Earth's gravity field, an objective physical entity/h-col-105.html, /h-nd-164.html
The metrological soulAll concepts, observables and parameters must, like the fundamental standards of physics, satisfy objective uniqueness, precise measurability and spatiotemporal unity/h-nd-164.html, Section 1.1
Reading Suggestions for This Report If your interest is the theoretical thread: Chapter 1 → Chapters 2–8 (the seven paradigm breakthroughs) → Chapter 9 (Geodesy for a Deforming Earth) → Chapter 12.
If your interest is engineering realization: Chapter 2 (reference frames), Chapter 3 (height datums), Chapter 6 (approximation methodology), and Chapter 10 (errors and the algorithm lineage).
1

Disciplinary Philosophy and Paradigm Innovation: Positioning Upgrade, Theoretical Foundation and Three Philosophical Tenets

The starting point of this body of academic thought is to answer anew “what this discipline is, by what standards it operates, and where it is heading”.

1.1Two Definitions of the Discipline (official wording)

Geodesy: a discipline that takes the Earth's physical body and Earth-fixed space as its objects of observation and study; it investigates and determines the Earth's figure in mechanical equilibrium and its external gravity field, the positions of points and their mutual spatial relationships, and monitors solid Earth deformation, gravity field variations, the kinematic trajectories of points and their spatiotemporal coherence. It is also a metrological science for the precise measurement of the Earth and the monitoring of global change.— ZHANG Chuanyin, 2025, Geodesy for a Deforming Earth, Chinese Science Press
Physical Geodesy: a theoretical geodesy that investigates and determines the Earth's figure and its external gravity field, studies the gravity field theory of terrestrial reference frames and height datums, and studies how the principles of the gravity field support the synergy of geometric and physical geodesy and the solution of geodetic disciplinary problems. It is also a metrological science for monitoring mass transport in the Earth system and gravity field variations.— ZHANG Chuanyin, 2026, Physical Geodesy, Chinese Science Press

1.2The Revolutionary Upgrade of the Disciplinary Positioning: Three Meanings

MeaningContent
First, the strong return of “theoretical geodesy”Through the intrinsic unification of the Earth's gravity field, the Earth-fixed reference system, the height datum and relativistic geodesy in Earth space, the foundational logic and theoretical system of the entire geodetic discipline are reshaped, thereby scientifically supporting the sustainable development of modern geodesy
Second, establishing the philosophical core of a “metrological science”All geodetic concepts, observables and parameters must, like the fundamental standards of physics, possess rigorous objective uniqueness, precise measurability and spatiotemporal unity, discarding any vague or assumption-dependent elements
Third, expanding the function of “Earth system analysis”By monitoring the fine spatiotemporal variations of the gravity field, the system explores Earth deformation, internal structure, mass transport and internal and external dynamic processes, directly serving major scientific problems such as Earth system evolution, global change monitoring and geo-environmental hazards
From official page /h-nd-164.html, Section 1.1; it stands in contrast to the traditional definition (the study and determination of the Earth's shape, size and external gravity field by means of gravity measurement and other techniques, providing a height datum for surveying and mapping and gravity field information for navigation and exploration).

1.3Why the Theoretical Foundation Must Be Reshaped

Separated fieldTraditional problemPositioning after unification
Terrestrial reference frameLimited by geophysical conventions and external agreements (e.g. the “No-Net-Rotation” condition and the historical convention for the reference pole), it suffers from the fundamental defects of “conventionality” and “non-uniqueness”Positioning and orientation are determined directly by the gravity field
Height datumAffected by assumptions about crustal density and by the uncertainty of terrain reduction, the Helmert orthometric height and the geoid fail to satisfy the requirements of uniqueness and measurabilityRebuilt on the uniquely invariant geopotential datum constant W₀
Relativistic geodesy in Earth spaceRelativistic effects remain largely confined to higher-order corrections of high-precision geodesy, and no engineered algorithmic framework adapted to the geopotential space of the Earth existsThe geopotential determines the spatiotemporal scales, and engineered algorithms are realized
Unified foundation—The Earth's gravity field is the natural and unique objective physical entity that carries the terrestrial reference frame, the height datum and relativistic geodesy in Earth space

1.4Three Philosophical Tenets for Upgrading the Disciplinary System

Three Fundamental Tenets = One System of Criteria The three tenets together form a rigorous system of criteria: all traditional concepts, methods and elements must pass this three-fold test; whatever satisfies it is inherited and developed, and whatever does not is resolutely corrected or de-emphasized. This profound intellectual “purification” endows modern geodesy with its metrological soul.
TenetRequirementTraditional “weak spot” it addresses
Principle of objective uniquenessEvery geodetic element (such as gravity, coordinates and height) must exist objectively and have a uniquely determined value under given conditions; it must not take several different solutions merely because the computation method or the model standard differsThe Helmert orthometric height depends on an unknown crustal density assumption, and the “true geoid” changes with the terrain mass adjustment scheme — neither satisfies uniqueness
Principle of precise measurabilityEvery geodetic element must be determinable with a certain accuracy by some observation or computation, and that accuracy must be assessable; theory must not remain at the level of abstract concepts or purely mathematical derivation, but must be implementable and verifiableThe quasi-geoid is “difficult to express uniquely”; definitions that rely on unmeasurable assumptions
Principle of spatiotemporal unityAgainst the background of a deforming Earth, the spatiotemporal variations of all elements (geometric coordinates and heights; physical geopotential and gravity) are merely different manifestations of the evolution of the Earth system, and must therefore be spatiotemporally coupled and mutually consistentCoordinate, height and gravity datums are established and maintained separately, and dynamic consistency lacks a system-level definition
The third tenet “directly gave rise to the new concept of an ‘integrated geodetic reference system for a deforming Earth’” (see Chapter 7).

1.5Four Upgrades of the Disciplinary Philosophy and System

Upgrade itemContent
Building a unified, self-consistent theoretical foundationSystematically constructing and rigorously proving the intrinsic analytical theoretical relations among the Earth's gravity field, the Earth-fixed reference system and the height datum; breaking the long-standing pattern in which geometric and physical geodesy developed relatively independently; and achieving the intrinsic unification of the entire geodetic discipline
Optimizing the foundational logic and cognitive paradigmUsing the three fundamental tenets as the instrument, it reviews, criticizes and discards redundant assumptions, approximate concepts and unnecessary complexities introduced into traditional theory by historical limitations of observation or technology; the goal is to “reduce unnecessary complexity” and to return the discipline to a focus on the measurability and the mathematical-physical essence of the gravity field itself
Driving a far-reaching strategic transformation of the disciplineGeodesy is no longer merely a service discipline that acquires position, height and gravity data, but is elevated into a core analytical and metrological science for understanding Earth system evolution, solid Earth deformation effects, the global water cycle and mass transport, and the internal and external dynamics of the Earth
Upgrading and completing the disciplinary knowledge systemFrom basic theory to modern methods, from formula derivation to scientific computing, from global approximation to local refinement, from all-element analytical modeling of the steady-state field to multi-element collaborative monitoring of the time-variable field, and from unified processing principles for multiple data types to quality-control strategies for algorithm performance — advancing an all-round upgrade of the discipline of physical geodesy and making it a core scientific support for Earth system evolution, global change monitoring, modernization of surveying and mapping datums, and the in-depth application of BeiDou/GNSS
From official page /h-nd-164.html, Section 1.4.

1.6Normative Constraints: Turning Philosophical Tenets into Technical Criteria

ConceptDefinitionRequirement to be satisfied
General geodetic elementsAll kinds of geodetic observables, parameters and target solutionsStrictly satisfy objective uniqueness and precise measurability
Geodetic datum constantsGeodetic elements that do not vary with timeStrictly satisfy unique invariance, precise measurability and conceptual independence from epochs and errors; this is termed the starting datum requirement of geodesy
From the official “Ideas & Philosophy” section. The technical requirements corresponding to these two classes of concepts are the normative constraints of the entire geodetic discipline.

1.7From Discipline to Platform: the Common Direction of Three Transformations

TransformationFromTo
Form of the discipline“Technical data service”“Earth system analysis”
Educational philosophy“Technology-oriented” knowledge transfer“Problem-driven” systems thinking and conceptual innovation
Courses and toolsFormula derivation and isolated softwareAn integrated “theory – courseware – software – examples” set: the monograph + teaching courseware (nine PPT decks, 48 class hours) + the two independent computing systems + complete examples
Chapter Summary What Chapter 1 establishes is the “criterion”: the three philosophical tenets and the normative constraints are the premise and the test standard on which every subsequent proposition in this report (reference frames, height datums, relativity, effect treatment, approximation methods, the integrated reference system and theoretical streamlining) depends.
2

Paradigm Breakthrough One: the Terrestrial Reference Frame — from “Convention” to “Determined by the Gravity Field”

Rewriting the reference frame from a “set of conventions” into a “measurable physical result”, and eradicating “conventionality” and “non-uniqueness”.

2.1Traditional Dilemma

Manifestation of the dilemmaNature of the problem
The temporal evolution of the ITRS orientation is constrained by the “No-Net-Rotation (NNR)” conditionThis is an artificial convention that cannot be verified
The IERS reference pole (axis) is conventionally anchored near the mean rotation pole of the 1900–1905 epochOnly historical continuity is considered; there is no physical basis
The ITRS has not established a direct and rigorous scientific linkage with the intrinsic physical properties of the EarthEssential elements such as the mass distribution, the moments of inertia and the Earth's gravity field do not enter the definition of the reference frame, giving rise to the fundamental problems of “conventionality” and “non-uniqueness”

2.2Original Breakthrough: Gravity Field-Determined Theory for the Orientation and Positioning of Terrestrial Reference Frames

Rigorous Derivation Result The first-degree terms of the geopotential uniquely determine the position of the Earth's center of mass in the Earth-fixed reference system; the second-degree, first-order terms uniquely determine the position of the figure pole (the direction of the polar axis of inertia). In this way, the origin and the z-axis of the reference frame can be determined directly and uniquely from the observable gravity field, thereby realizing an Earth-fixed reference system that does not depend on any external convention, is independent of the Earth's rotational motion, is defined entirely by geodetic theory itself, and is scientifically self-consistent.
Reference-frame elementTraditional practiceGravity field determinism
Origin (3 constants)The mean center of mass constrained by conventions and external agreementsThe first-degree terms of the geopotential uniquely determine the position of the Earth's center of mass in the Earth-fixed reference system
Axial direction / reference pole (2 constants)Conventionally anchored near the mean rotation pole of the 1900–1905 epochThe second-degree, first-order terms of the geopotential uniquely determine the figure pole (the direction of the polar axis of inertia)
Zero meridian (1 constant)The reference meridian and the conventional x-axis orientation (the Non-Rotating Origin of the GCRS)Participates in the unification as one of the geodetic datum constants; it connects with the unified theory of reference-frame spatiotemporal scales

2.3Revolutionary Significance

LevelContent
First level: philosophy and conceptsIt philosophically eradicates the century-old problems of “conventionality” and “non-uniqueness” in terrestrial reference frames; it completely discards any geophysical convention assumption, is independent of the Earth's rotational motion, and realizes a scientifically self-consistent “natural” mechanical reference system governed by first principles and derived solely from the observable Earth's gravity field
Second level: theory and applicationIt clarifies the direct correlation between the Earth's figure axis (the principal axis of inertia) and the geopotential coefficients, which not only advances the reshaping of the Earth's spatiotemporal framework but also provides an objective, physically natural theoretical basis for the synergy of geometric and physical geodesy
From official pages /h-col-105.html and /h-nd-164.html, Section 2.1.

2.4From Theory to Observables: Joint Monitoring of the Center of Mass, the Figure Pole and Earth Rotation Parameters

The official article page /h-nd-160.html (published in Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica) gives the route by which this theory becomes monitorable: it resolves the geophysical uncertainty in the definition of the terrestrial reference frame and creates a gravity field theory for the positioning and orientation of the Earth — rigorously deriving a purely geodetic theory and algorithms for the positioning and orientation of the terrestrial reference frame, discarding geodynamic assumptions and the conventional terrestrial reference system, establishing analytical relations between the Earth's gravity field and the reference frame, and updating the theoretical foundation of geodesy from the very root of the discipline.

Main result of the paperContent
① Positioning theoretical methodA theoretical method for determining the position of the Earth's center of mass and the figure pole through the synergy of spatial geometric and physical geodesy is derived: it can precisely monitor the time series of Earth center of mass variations and figure pole shifts, and can position and orient the current Earth-fixed reference system to the mean center of mass and the mean figure pole of a specified period
② Joint monitoring modelA monitoring model and algorithms for the “joint determination of the Earth's center of mass, the figure pole and various Earth rotation dynamic parameters” are given, based on the synergy of Earth satellite observations, VLBI kinematic measurements, and radial displacements and gravity variations at ground stations, so as to improve the constraints for research on the mechanisms of Earth rotation dynamics
③ Problem addressedInternal mass adjustments and mass motion in the Earth cannot be measured accurately, which makes the Earth rotation excitation functions inferred from geophysical fluid data uncertain and constrains in-depth study of the mechanisms of Earth rotation dynamics — this work resolves that uncertainty by unifying the datum of the Earth-fixed reference system
The same page also notes that the rigorous redefinition and scientific realization of the terrestrial reference frame may be consulted in Chapter 7 of Geodesy for a Deforming Earth (Chinese Science Press, 2025); the page keywords are “Earth-fixed reference system, Earth's center of mass, Earth's figure pole, Earth rotation dynamics, geodetic synergy, geophysical excitation”.

2.5Where This Theory Is Implemented in the Platform

Platform elementRelation to the reference-frame theory
Chapter 4 of the courseware: gravity field-determined theory of the terrestrial reference frameThe corresponding entry point for classroom teaching and self-study (/h-nd-169.html)
Chapter 8 of the courseware: vertical datums unified in the Earth-fixed reference systemAn extension of the reference-frame theory towards vertical datums (/h-nd-173.html)
Subsystem ① of ETideLoad4.5, “Computation of Various Tidal and Polar Shift Effects on All Geodetic Elements”Analytical computation of rotation polar shift effects, tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters, and the effects of Earth center of mass variation and figure pole shifts
Source-code modulesCodes for computing Earth ellipsoid constants (/h-nd-118), Fortran codes for Earth center of mass variation effects (/h-nd-122), codes for forecasting ocean tidal load effects on the Earth's center of mass (/h-nd-127), codes for computing all-element rotation polar shift effects (/h-nd-56), Fortran codes for forecasting tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters (ERP) (/h-nd-150)
Algorithm documents“Computation of rotation polar shift effects and tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters” and “Computation of Earth center of mass variation and figure pole shift effects” (Downloads and Resources section)
Chapter Summary The reference-frame theory addresses a foundational problem: the reference frame is no longer “a pile of agreed conventions”, but “a set of physical quantities computed from geopotential coefficients”; the reference-frame datum and the gravity field theory are thereby connected within one and the same analytical system.
3

Paradigm Breakthrough Two: the Height Datum — Clarifying a Century-Old Confusion and Consolidating the Modern Height Datum

Turning the “dispute over level surfaces” into a “distinction between the datum constant and its geometric realization”.

3.1Traditional Predicament: Three Core “Deficiencies”

DeficiencyOfficial argumentConsequence
Deficiency 1: the classical Helmert orthometric heightIts definition relies on the assumption of an average crustal density between the ground point and the geoid. However, crustal density is unknown and spatially heterogeneousThis directly renders the Helmert orthometric height “non-unique” at the centimeter level
Deficiency 2: the so-called “true geoid”By adjusting topographic masses into the interior of the geoid, a modified equipotential surface is obtained; but it depends severely on the terrain mass adjustment scheme, and different adjustment methods give different resultsDiscrepancies reach the decimeter level; it possesses neither uniqueness nor measurability
Deficiency 3: the quasi-geoidIt is obtained indirectly by determining height anomalies at the Earth's surface; the actual heights of measuring points above the ground possess random uncertainties, and the digital elevation models used to represent the terrain are inherently diverseThe quasi-geoid is difficult to express uniquely
The common cause of all three: none of them satisfies the principle of “uniqueness and measurability”.

3.2Theoretical Innovation Scheme: Separating the Datum Constant from the Geometric Quantity

Core Proposition The geoidal potential W₀ is the truly unique, invariant height starting datum constant, conceptually free from epochs and errors. The geoid is a “geometric quantity”: it is merely the geometric realization of this physical datum constant on a deforming Earth — the geoid changes with time because the Earth deforms, but the physical datum behind it, the geopotential W₀, remains eternally invariant.
New conceptDefinitionProperty acquired
Analytical GeoidAn equipotential surface defined by analytical continuation of the external gravity fieldDetermined entirely by the measurable external gravity field, which guarantees uniqueness and measurability
Analytical Orthometric HeightThe geometric height corresponding to the Analytical GeoidAs above; the official site recommends it as more suitable for height datum purposes than other types of orthometric height
Official conclusion: these conceptual innovations “give GNSS Replacing Leveling a solid theoretical foundation and provide a clear scientific path towards unifying the global height datum in the future”.

3.3The Geoid, the Global Geopotential and the Normal Gravity Field

No.Proposition (key points of the official wording)
1According to the Gauss-Listing definition, the geoid is the equipotential surface that best fits the global mean sea level; it is essentially a specified convention. Its geopotential is termed the Earth's geopotential constant, also known as the global geopotential W₀
2The geoid is the specific equipotential surface whose geopotential is conventionally fixed at the constant W₀, and its geometric positioning is expressed by the geoidal (ellipsoidal) height; the geoid can only exist by attaching to the Earth-fixed reference system. Before computing the geoidal height, a normal ellipsoid must be specified in advance, and the normal geopotential on the normal ellipsoid surface must satisfy U₀ = W₀
3Of the four constants of the normal ellipsoid, GM and ω are measured quantities; of the remaining two, one is the Earth's semi-major axis a and the other may be chosen from the dynamic form factor J₂, the normal geopotential U₀ on the ellipsoid surface, or the geometric flattening f. One of the latter two must be specified by convention before the other becomes measurable
4The implementation principle for a W₀ analytically consistent with the gravimetric geoid: first estimate the semi-major axis a from the best global geopotential coefficient model together with a global mean sea surface height model, following the Gauss-Listing geoid convention; then use the measured second-degree zonal harmonic coefficient C̅₂₀ in the model (consistent with a), together with GM and ω, to form the four fundamental constants of the normal ellipsoid; analytically compute the normal geopotential U₀ on the normal ellipsoid surface; finally, define U₀ as the global geopotential constant W₀, thereby scientifically realizing W₀ = U₀ and the rigorous unification of the physical definition of the geoid (W₀) with its geometric definition (the geoidal height)
5The geopotential coefficient expansion shows that determining or expressing the entire external gravity field does not require prior knowledge of the normal gravity field and the geoid (the geopotential value); once the external geopotential is fully determined, the geoid can be expressed directly in the Earth-fixed coordinate reference system from its conventional constant value W₀
6Both the normal gravity field and the global geopotential W₀ are conventional; once a geodetic element of conventional nature has been agreed, it should remain uniquely invariant and not vary with time over a long period (e.g. 20 years), so as to guarantee the uniqueness of the associated field quantities and the analytical compatibility of the relations among them

3.4Applicability of the Geoid as the Zero-Height Surface

PropositionKey points of the argument
The dual nature of orthometric (normal) heightIt is defined in the Earth-fixed coordinate reference system by gravity field theory and possesses uniqueness and measurability; but the physical meaning it represents (the geopotential number) can only be approximate — this is inherent in the definition
Unified starting surface for the three systemsAt a ground point where the normal height is zero, the orthometric height and the geopotential number are likewise zero and its geopotential equals the geoidal potential constant, so the point must lie on the geoid. Hence the zero orthometric height surface and the zero normal height surface are the equipotential surface on which the geopotential number equals zero, and they coincide with the geoid. Whether the orthometric height system, the normal height system or the geopotential number system is used, the height starting surface is the (global or regional) geoid
The starting datum constant is uniqueThe definition of the height system prescribes that the geoidal potential W₀ is its unique starting datum constant; the geometric realization of this constant in the Earth-fixed reference system is the geoid
Geometric deformation of the geoidThe geopotential W changes objectively with the redistribution of internal mass in the Earth, causing the geopotential number or geometric height of any point to vary with time; the difference in “geoidal height” between two epochs is accordingly defined as the geometric deformation of the geoid

3.5Problems Arising from Using the Quasi-Geoid as the Datum Surface

ProblemArgument
Contradiction with the definition of normal heightThe zero normal height surface has a geopotential number of zero and is therefore the geoid, not the so-called quasi-geoid
Uniqueness does not holdFor two points with the same latitude and longitude but different heights, the height anomalies are unequal; if the normal height were reckoned from the quasi-geoid, two non-coincident starting points in the vertical direction would be required
Correction required in practical applicationActual measuring points do not usually fall exactly on the particular digital elevation model surface chosen when constructing the ground height anomaly model; in centimeter-level applications, a height-dependent height anomaly gradient (or gravity disturbance) correction must be added
How the platform handles itPAGravf4.5 de-emphasizes the concept of the quasi-geoid and does not treat it as the starting surface of normal heights; its height anomaly is strictly in one-to-one correspondence with the spatial position

3.6Geometric Properties and Conceptual Updating of the Height Systems

SystemGeometric property (official argument)Advantages and limitations
Orthometric height systemThe ellipsoidal height difference ΔH₁₂ between two orthometric equi-height surfaces equals their orthometric height difference Δh₁₂; hence orthometric equi-height surfaces are mutually parallel in the Earth-fixed reference system and independent of the geoidal height N. Within a local area, orthometric equi-height surfaces are parallel to the geoid and have the same geometric shape. It follows that the orthometric height is the height of the straight-line distance from a ground point to the geoid along the direction perpendicular to the geoidIt has a more intuitive geometric measurement property; the customary view that the orthometric height is “the length of an irregular curve along the plumb line” has no geodetic basis and is incorrect
Normal height systemIt possesses uniqueness and measurability; however, because the height anomaly varies with height, normal equi-height surfaces are not strictly parallel in the Earth-fixed reference system; the height anomaly signal attenuates as height increases, so the shape of a normal equi-height surface becomes progressively smoother relative to the geoid as height increasesCloser to the nature of the gravity field
Official conclusion: the orthometric and normal height systems “each have their own advantages, limitations and scientific applications, and both have their necessity and scientific justification”.

3.7Principles of Regional Gravity Field and Geoid Refinement

Principle of Stepwise Control The geoidal height and other gravity field quantities at any point can only be determined precisely with observation gravity field data covering the globe; regional observation data cannot fully contain the medium- and long-wavelength information. Moreover, for field elements determined by gravity field approximation, the longer the wavelength (the larger the spatial scale), the higher the accuracy generally. Regional refinement should therefore adopt a suitable global geopotential coefficient model as the reference gravity field and as the outer-boundary constraint of the region to control medium- and long-wavelength errors, and then integrate observation gravity field resources in and around the region to improve medium- and short-wavelength accuracy. For local areas such as a province or a city, a regional gravity field model should serve as the reference gravity field to control the accumulation of medium- and short-wavelength errors — that is, the principle of stepwise control: “for gravimetric geoid refinement in a small area, take a gravity field model of a larger area as the reference gravity field and the far-field outer-boundary condition”.
Fusion of GNSS leveling and the gravimetric level surfaceKey point
The essence of levelingLeveling transmits height differences station by station and is essentially the measurement of the geopotential difference between two leveling points; in principle its relative error is independent of the length of the leveling line
Division of spatial scalesFor any given region there exists a spatial scale: below that scale, the relative accuracy of the gravimetric height anomaly difference between two points is lower than that of the GNSS-leveling height anomaly difference
Requirements on the fusion algorithmThe high-precision medium- and long-wavelength components of the gravimetric height anomaly should be effectively integrated with the high-precision short- and ultra-short-wavelength components of the GNSS-leveling control network; in error handling, short-wavelength gravimetric height anomaly errors should be suppressed while the accumulation of long-distance GNSS-leveling height anomaly errors is controlled
Requirements on the observation modelAfter being incorporated into the Earth-fixed reference system and reduced to the global height datum, the GNSS-leveling height anomaly should be able to serve as a general observed field quantity participating in gravity field and geoid approximation modeling

3.8Six Basic Conclusions of the Related Research (/h-nd-161.html)

No.Key points of the conclusion
①Orthometric (normal) heights are defined by gravity field theory in the Earth-fixed reference system and possess uniqueness and precise measurability, but their physical meaning (the geopotential number) is approximate, and the geometric height has a typically local character
②A theoretical method for determining the position of the Earth's center of mass and the figure pole through the synergy of spatial geometric and physical geodesy is derived; it does not rely on geophysical assumptions or dynamic protocols and realizes the positioning and orientation of the reference frame entirely through geodetic theory
③A method of determining the global geopotential W₀ that is analytically compatible with the gravimetric geoid is recommended; it is also demonstrated that the normal gravity field has only 3 degrees of freedom and is likewise a unique and precisely measurable element of physical geodesy
④The concept of the height starting datum surface is updated: after neglecting the geometric deformation of the geoid, the starting surface of all three height systems is the (global or regional) geoid; at decimeter-level accuracy requirements, the quasi-geoid should not be used as the starting datum surface of normal heights
⑤The theoretical foundation of the height datum gravity field unified in the Earth-fixed reference system is perfected, the datum conditions and implementation principles of GNSS Replacing Leveling are derived, and the Analytical Orthometric Height is recommended as more suitable for height datum purposes
⑥Orthometric equi-height surfaces are parallel to the geoid, and the orthometric height is the height of the straight-line distance from a ground point to the geoid along the vertical direction
The official site also notes that this paper is openly discussed in the message board, for open debate and academic exchange.

3.9Where This Theory Is Implemented in the Platform

Platform elementContent
Subsystem ④ of PAGravf4.5Optimization, Unification, and Application of Regional Height Datums
Chapter 6 of the coursewareHeight datums and their gravity field theory (/h-nd-171.html)
Chapter 8 of the coursewareVertical datums unified in the Earth-fixed reference system: rigorous definition and scientific realization of the geodetic reference system for a deforming Earth; global realization, regional construction and integrated maintenance of the vertical reference frame (/h-nd-173.html)
Algorithm documents“Updating the concepts and philosophy of height systems and height datums”, “Principles and requirements for regional gravity field and geoid modeling”, “Process for computing Complete Bouguer gravity disturbances on a mean terrain elevation surface”
Source-code modulesComputing the radial variation rate of the height anomaly from a gravity field model (/h-nd-78), computing the difference between orthometric and normal heights from a gravity field model (/h-nd-79), computing geopotential differences and ellipsoidal height differences between orthometric (normal) equi-height surfaces (/h-nd-80), construction of a model gravity equipotential surface through a specified point (/h-nd-81), codes for computing Earth ellipsoid constants (/h-nd-118)
Chapter Summary The essence of rebuilding the height datum is to separate the “datum” from its “geometric realization”: the constant is uniquely invariant while the geometry varies with deformation. This unifies the starting surface of the three height systems, yields a measurable analytical level surface, and provides the executable principles of stepwise control and GNSS/leveling fusion, while laying the theoretical foundation for “GNSS Replacing Leveling”.
4

Paradigm Breakthrough Three: Relativistic Geodesy — from an Abstract Conceptual Theory to Engineered Algorithms

Engineering the post-Newtonian theory of general relativity into the geopotential space of the Earth, so that the definition of the spatiotemporal scales acquires a deeper physical basis.

4.1Traditional Limitation: Why Relativistic Effects Long Remained “a Correction Term”

Traditional situationDescription
Confined to higher-order correctionsRelativistic effects remained largely confined to higher-order corrections of high-precision geodesy
Lack of an engineered algorithmic frameworkNo engineered algorithmic framework adapted to the geopotential space of the Earth existed, so relativistic treatment could hardly enter routine measurement computation chains
Separated from reference frames and height datumsThe definition and realization of the spatiotemporal scales lacked analytical linkage with the gravity field and could only rely on external conventions and agreements

4.2Theoretical Point of Entry: the Geopotential Determines the Spatiotemporal Scales

Physical Basis According to the relativistic principle of the contraction of the second length in gravity field space, the spatially inhomogeneous distribution of the Earth's geopotential directly causes the non-uniformity of the temporal and spatial scales in Earth space; the Earth's gravity field is the theoretical foundation for unifying the spatiotemporal scales of the terrestrial reference frame. (Official “Ideas & Philosophy” section)
Engineered contentDescription
2PN spacetime metricThe 2PN spacetime metric of the Geocentric Celestial Reference System is given in full, providing a rigorous basis for relativistic computation in the Earth environment
Proper-clock second-length contractionThe proper-clock second-length contraction relation applicable to the Earth environment is derived
Realization of terrestrial coordinate timeA method for realizing terrestrial coordinate time is given, so that the time scale can be coordinated with the space scale
Metre-length dilationThe metre-length dilation relation coordinated with the realization of coordinate time is given
Relativistic measurement of the geopotential differenceA formula for the relativistic measurement of the geopotential difference is established, taking relativistic geodesy across the gap from theory to algorithms
From official page /h-nd-164.html, Section 2.3.

4.3The Dual Value in Theory and in Practice

DimensionValue
Theoretical valueIt completes the unification of relativistic effects with geodetic theory, giving the definition and realization of the spatiotemporal scales a deeper physical basis; it is the realization of the “relativistic geodesy in Earth space” branch of the “four-in-one” cornerstone
Practical valueIt provides rigorous relativistic algorithms for high-precision time comparison and space ranging; more importantly, it lays a complete theoretical and algorithmic foundation for the future use of optical atomic clocks to determine height differences directly and remotely, achieving unprecedented precision measurement unified in space and time
Echoing the “Principle of Spatiotemporal Unity” The third tenet of Chapter 1 requires that the spatiotemporal variations of geometric and physical quantities “must be spatiotemporally coupled and mutually consistent”. The engineering of relativistic geodesy is precisely the algorithmic expression of this tenet at the level of the time scale and the length scale: geopotential difference → clock frequency difference → measurable spatiotemporal quantity, turning “spatiotemporal unity” from a philosophical statement into a computable relation.

4.4Relativity-Related Modules and Resources in the Platform

Platform elementContent
Chapter 4 of the coursewareGravity field-determined theory of the terrestrial reference frame (including the unification of the Earth-fixed reference system with relativistic geodesy in Earth space) (/h-nd-169.html)
Basic computation packages (Source Codes section)Fortran source code of the geodetic coordinate transformation package (/h-nd-39), Fortran source code of the geodetic time system conversion package (/h-nd-40)
Satellite orbit perturbation computationRigorous computation of solid Earth tidal perturbations of Earth satellite orbits (/h-nd-58), precise computation of ocean tidal load perturbations of Earth satellite orbits (/h-nd-59), computation of atmospheric tidal load perturbations of Earth satellite orbits (/h-nd-60), computation of non-tidal surface environmental load perturbations of satellite orbits (/h-nd-64)
Permanent tide and rotation effectsComputation of all geodetic elements of the permanent tide on the ground (/h-nd-61), codes for computing all-element rotation polar shift effects (/h-nd-56), Fortran codes for forecasting tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters (ERP) (/h-nd-150)
Numerical basisComputation of normal Earth gravity field parameters (/h-nd-24), computation of Legendre functions and their derivatives (/h-nd-25), computation of even-degree normal gravity potential coefficients (/h-nd-26), computation of ultra-high-degree normalized associated Legendre functions and their derivatives (/h-nd-27, /h-nd-89)
The source-code module pages and courseware pages listed above all come from the official site and demonstrate how relativity and normal gravity field computation are carried in the geopotential space of the Earth.
Chapter Summary The significance of engineering relativistic geodesy lies in this: it brings “spatiotemporal scales” — an element long regarded as an external conventional condition — into a computation system determined directly by the geopotential. Thereby the reference frame, the height datum and relativity truly return to one and the same physical foundation, forming the branch of the “four-in-one” cornerstone that is hardest to engineer.
5

Paradigm Breakthrough Four: All-Element Effect Treatment — a Unified, Analytically Compatible Integration Framework

Bringing terrain effects, solid Earth tides, ocean and atmospheric loads, and non-tidal load deformation effects into one and the same framework of standards and algorithms.

5.1Traditional Problem: Three Classes of Effects Treated in Isolation

Traditional problemManifestation and consequence
Dispersed treatmentTerrain corrections, tidal corrections and load corrections are often treated in isolation in different textbooks and different software packages
Inconsistent standardsAlgorithmic standards are not unified; the same effect is implemented differently in different sources
Limited applicabilityIt is difficult to meet the needs of all-element geodetic processing across space, air, land and sea

5.2Official Innovation: a Unified Effect-Treatment Paradigm

Paradigm Content A unified effect-treatment paradigm applicable to all geometric and physical geodetic elements (position, height, gravity, gradients, vertical deflections, etc.) is established; it systematically integrates terrain effects, solid Earth tides, ocean loads, atmospheric loads and non-tidal load deformation effects, and it particularly emphasizes that all algorithms must satisfy Analytical Compatibility — this is the basic condition and the minimum requirement for the deep fusion of multi-source geometric and physical geodetic data and for the collaborative operation of diverse heterogeneous geodetic techniques.
Effect categorySourcePlatform support
Terrain effectsDifferences in the terrain/crustal mass adjustment scheme (Local Terrain Effect, Terrain Bouguer Effect, Seawater Bouguer Effect, Isostatic Effect, Helmert Condensation Effect, Residual Terrain Effect, etc.)Subsystem ② of PAGravf4.5; algorithm document “Algorithmic framework for terrain effects on all-element gravity field quantities external to the Earth”
Solid Earth tidesCelestial tide-generating potentialSubsystem ① of ETideLoad4.5; algorithm document “Unified computation of solid Earth tidal effects on all elements on the ground and external to the solid Earth”
Ocean tidal loadOcean tidal loadingAlgorithm document “Global load tide harmonic analysis and spherical harmonic synthesis of load tide effects”; source-code modules /h-nd-43, /h-nd-44
Atmospheric tidal loadAtmospheric tidal loadingSource-code modules “Direct effect of atmospheric pressure tides on the Earth's geopotential coefficients” (/h-nd-45) and “Global forecasting of ground/sea-surface atmospheric pressure by spherical harmonic synthesis” (/h-nd-38)
Non-tidal load deformation effectsNon-tidal variations of environmental loads such as soil and vegetation moisture, river-lake-reservoir water, glaciers, ice sheets and snow, groundwater, atmosphere and sea levelSubsystem ③ of ETideLoad4.5; algorithm documents “Global load spherical harmonic analysis and spherical harmonic synthesis of the load deformation field”, “Load Green's function and spatial-domain integral algorithms for load effects”, “SRBF approximation of surface loads and SRBF synthesis of load effects”

5.3Tidal Deformation and Geodetic Tidal Effects: Four Propositions

No.Proposition
1Periodic deformations of the solid Earth and associated temporal variations of the Earth's gravity field, excited by the celestial tide-generating potential, ocean tides and atmospheric tides external to the Earth, are termed the tidal deformation of the solid Earth
2The periodic variations of geodetic elements (observables or parameters) caused by the celestial tide-generating potential, ocean tides and atmospheric tides are usually termed the tidal effects (tidal influences) on those elements
3Geodetic tidal effects comprise solid Earth tidal effects and tidal load effects: the former are excited by the celestial tide-generating potential, the latter by ocean tidal loading or atmospheric tidal loading
4Geodetic tidal effects can be modeled and accurately removed or restored at any time and place; a tidal effect equals the negative value of its tidal correction. A reference frame for which only tidal corrections are applied and non-tidal effects are neglected remains static or stationary

5.4Forms of Non-Tidal Deformation and Their Geodetic Influence

FormCause and manifestationMechanical nature
Load deformationNon-tidal variations of surface-system environmental loads cause changes in the Earth's geopotential (direct effect) and simultaneously excite solid Earth deformation (indirect effect), manifesting as ground vertical deformation, ground gravity and ground tilt variations, including temporal variations of the Earth's gravity fieldElastic deformation, quantitatively characterized by load Love numbers
Plastic isostatic vertical deformationGroundwater use, resource extraction, underground engineering construction, glacier and ice sheet melting and other natural or artificial surface mass changes cause shallow rock and soil to lose their original equilibrium and slowly tend towards another equilibriumPlastic deformation, with the dynamic action located in the subsurface rock and soil
From “Can Be Modeled” to a “Dynamic Frame” Non-tidal effects are difficult to model and are generally determined by geodetic techniques; where rapid or real-time applications require it, the measured non-tidal effect time series can be extrapolated by short-term prediction. A reference frame that accounts for non-tidal effects can only be a dynamic frame: the reference value corresponds to a unique reference epoch, and the reference value at the current epoch = the reference value at the reference epoch + (non-tidal effect) epoch reduction.

5.5Presentation of the Unified Framework in the Platform

Platform elementContent
Chapter 3 of the courseware: terrain effects, tidal and load effectsOfficial wording: the terrain effect, tidal effect and load effect on Earth gravity field quantities refer specifically to the contributions to the gravity field from terrain masses, the celestial tide-generating force, ocean and atmospheric tidal loading, and internal mass adjustments of the Earth (non-tidal variations of atmosphere, ocean and terrestrial water, etc.); they therefore coexist in all gravity field quantities in Earth space. Using the same standards and analytically compatible algorithms to treat uniformly the terrain effects and the tidal and load deformation effects on all geodetic and gravity field quantities in space, air, land and sea is a binding principle and restrictive requirement of physical geodesy (/h-nd-168.html)
Technical feature ① of ETideLoad4.5Strictly adopting scientifically unified standards and analytically compatible algorithms, it precisely computes the solid Earth, ocean and atmospheric tidal load effects, polar shift effects, Earth center of mass variation effects and permanent tide effects on all geodetic elements on the ground and external to the solid Earth, realizing global forecasting of all kinds of tidal effects on all geodetic elements on the ground
Source-code modules (effect lineage)Fortran source code for all-element solid Earth tidal effects (/h-nd-57), codes for computing all-element rotation polar shift effects (/h-nd-56), direct effect of ocean tidal loads on the Earth's geopotential coefficients (/h-nd-43), source code for spherical harmonic synthesis of ocean tidal load effects (/h-nd-44), direct effect of atmospheric pressure tides on the Earth's geopotential coefficients (/h-nd-45), computation of all geodetic elements of the permanent tide on the ground (/h-nd-61), source code for building load spherical harmonic coefficient model time series (/h-nd-62), codes for all-element spherical harmonic synthesis of load effects (/h-nd-63)
Chapter Summary The value of the unified effect-treatment paradigm lies not in “computing a few more corrections”, but in transforming effect treatment from “a collection of empirical operations” into “an algorithmic system with unified standards and analytically compatible constraints”; it is the key intermediate layer through which the “four-in-one” theory enters engineering practice, and it is also the premise of multi-source data fusion.
6

Paradigm Breakthrough Five: Gravity Field Approximation Methodology — Collaborative Inversion in the Era of Big Space-Air-Land-Sea Data

Moving from the classical integral theory of “a single data type and a single boundary surface” towards “collaborative approximation by multi-source heterogeneous observation systems”.

6.1Traditional Limitations

LimitationDescription
A single data typeThe classical integral theory of gravity field boundary value problems is generally based on a single data type (e.g. terrestrial gravity)
A single boundary surfaceIt is generally based on a single boundary surface (e.g. the geoid)
Limited fusion capabilityIt can hardly fuse effectively the multi-source heterogeneous gravity field observations from space, air, land and sea, such as satellite gravity, satellite altimetry, GNSS leveling, gravity gradients and vertical deflections

6.2Official Development: Collaborative Approximation Theory for Multi-Source Heterogeneous Observation Systems

Four Paths ① To analyse the theoretical relation between spatial-domain boundary value problem integrals and spectral-domain geopotential coefficient representation; ② to develop Spherical Radial Basis Function (SRBF) approximation methods; ③ to create a collaborative approximation theory for multi-source heterogeneous observation systems, so as to fuse flexibly and efficiently multi-source heterogeneous data with extreme distributions; ④ through observation-system grouping, normal equation normalization and system weight optimization, to achieve the strongest data fusion capability for global gravity field inversion and local gravity field refinement, so as to maximize the direct observation potential of the Earth's gravity field.

6.3The Realization in PAGravf4.5: a Dual System of Spatial-Domain Integrals and Spectral-Domain SRBF

SystemContent (official wording)
Overall scientific objectiveStrictly following the requirements of gravity field approximation theory: to solve the problem of diverse terrain effects on various types of gravity field elements in the external space of the Earth; to realize closed-loop operations of the analytical relations among external disturbing field elements, all-element analytical modeling of the gravity field in full external space, and 1 cm steady-state geoid refinement
Spatial-domain boundary value integralsDerived from the Stokes boundary value problem: the regularized Stokes integral, Hotine integral, Vening-Meinesz (V-M) integral, radial gradient integral, etc.; accompanied by generalized Stokes/Hotine integrals and inverse operation modules (see the lineage in 6.4)
Spectral-domain SRBF approximationA scientifically complete algorithmic framework of spatial-domain forward and inverse integral operations and spectral-domain radial basis function approximation is developed, realizing all-element analytical modeling of the regional gravity field in full external space from multi-source, heterogeneous, varying-altitude, cross-distributed and land-sea aliased observations
Strong constraints from analytical relationsTaking the analytical functional relations between field elements as a strong constraint, it deeply fuses multi-source heterogeneous gravity field observations at different altitudes, cross-aliased and coexisting on land and at sea, and therefore requires no gravity reduction, continuation or gridding operations

(1) Three technical characteristics of the gravity field integral algorithms

CharacteristicContent
Fixed integration radiusThe definition domain of the kernel function is controlled to realize gravity field integration with a fixed radius, including numerical integration and fast FFT integral algorithms (with kernel windowing), so as to coordinate and unify the various gravity field approximation algorithms; the two-dimensional FFT adopts a modified planar 2-D kernel function, whose computation accuracy within 10° of latitude shows no appreciable difference from the one-dimensional FFT
Point positions and integration distancesPoint geodetic coordinates are always expressed by latitude, longitude and ellipsoidal height (the boundary surface position, measuring points, computation points and integration flowing points); integration grid positions take the geodetic coordinates of the cell grid centre; integration distances are always computed in geodetic coordinates
Gravity equipotential boundary surfaceMost integral formulas are derived from the Stokes boundary value problem and require the boundary surface to be an equipotential surface; because residual field elements are insensitive to position, an ellipsoidal height accuracy of no less than 10 m for representing the boundary surface position is sufficient, which can be constructed with a degree-360 geopotential coefficient model, and in near-Earth space an equi-orthometric (equi-normal) height surface ellipsoidal height grid may be used instead

(2) Three key measures of radial basis function analytical approximation

MeasureProblem addressed
Edge effect suppression as an alternative to normal equation regularizationWhen an SRBF centre point lies at the edge of the computation region, its SRBF coefficient is set to zero as an observation equation, improving the stability and reliability of coefficient estimation; once introduced, the normal equations no longer need regularization, thus preventing the field elements and their analytical relations from being affected by observation errors
Cumulative SRBF approximation for optimal recoveryBy combining the spectral centres and bandwidths of several SRBFs, the spectral signal of the target field element is fully resolved, achieving optimal recovery of the target field element in the spatial domain and avoiding spectral leakage of the target field element to be determined; each stage of residual approximation essentially treats the previous result as the reference field and refines the residual target field element by the remove-restore scheme
Normal equation normalization for fusing heterogeneous observation systemsBy normalizing the normal equations of different groups, the fusion of the covariance structures of each observation group is controlled, decoupling the influence of the “observation system model” from that of “observation quality (errors, gross errors)”, so that the fusion is unaffected by observation errors, observation type or differences in point distribution; this is advantageous for fusing data with extreme spatial distributions (e.g. very few astronomical vertical deflections or GNSS-leveling data)
Supporting technical features: ① the field elements have rigorous analytical relations among them, so the algorithmic performance is unaffected by observation field element errors; ② heterogeneous, varying-altitude, cross-distributed and land-sea coexisting observations of many kinds are analytically fused in one step, without reduction, continuation or gridding; ③ all-element analytical modeling of the geoid and of the gravity field in full external space is realized simultaneously; ④ the system provides gross error detection, external accuracy metrics, determination of height datum differences and computational performance control.

6.4Reconstruction of the Boundary Value Problem Classification: by “Whether the Boundary Surface Is an Equipotential Surface”

The official site points out that distinguishing the nature of gravity field boundary value problems by the classical first, second and third boundary value problems of potential theory can hardly describe the characteristics of the integral solutions effectively: if the boundary value is a vertical deflection, a gravity gradient or another type of disturbing gravity field quantity, no corresponding potential-theory boundary value problem can express it; and although the Stokes and Molodensky problems both belong to the third boundary value problem and share the same derivation process, the forms of their solutions differ significantly, and solving the Molodensky problem is far more complex than solving the Stokes problem.

The Classification Adopted by PAGravf4.5 Observed field quantities are mostly acquired in the local horizontal (level and plumb line) system of the measuring point. Accordingly, and according to whether the boundary surface is an equipotential surface, all external boundary value problems whose boundary value is “a linear combination of partial derivatives of the disturbing potential in the local horizontal system” are divided into two classes: the Stokes-type problem (the boundary surface is an equipotential surface) and the Molodensky-type problem (the boundary surface is not an equipotential surface).
No.Four approaches when the boundary surface is not an equipotential surface
1Analytically continue the boundary-surface gravity field quantities (such as surface gravity anomalies or vertical deflections) onto a gravity equipotential surface close to the boundary surface, so that the boundary surface becomes an equipotential surface and the boundary value problem is turned into a Stokes problem
2Apply to the boundary-surface gravity field quantities a correction from the inner normal direction of the boundary surface to the plumb line direction, thereby turning the boundary value problem into a Stokes problem
3Solve the Molodensky boundary value problem directly on the non-equipotential surface by the integral method
4Solve the Molodensky boundary value problem by spectral-domain least squares approximation
Official recommendation: boundary value problems should be addressed mainly by Stokes-type solution methods; the Molodensky boundary value theory may be used for the reduction of gravity field data to a gravity equipotential surface and for the quantitative analysis of the error influence of gravity field information approximation when processing data on non-equipotential surfaces, etc.

6.5Presentation of the Methodology in the Platform: the Algorithm and Source-Code Lineage

Lineage groupOfficial source-code modules (examples)
Integrals and inverse operationsPoisson integral computation for various field elements external to the Earth (/h-nd-69), codes for radial gradient numerical integration of disturbing field elements (/h-nd-68), computation of external disturbing gravity from disturbing gravity gradient integrals (/h-nd-72), computation of disturbing gravity gradients by inverse integral operation (/h-nd-73), inverse Stokes/Hotine/Vening-Meinesz operations (/h-nd-66), source code for inverting other disturbing field elements from the height anomaly (/h-nd-67), generalized Stokes/Hotine integrals (/h-nd-94)
Terrain effects and condensationFortran code for rigorous integration of Local Terrain Effects (/h-nd-124), Fortran code for Helmert condensation integration (/h-nd-47), code for rigorous integration of land-sea Complete Bouguer effects (/h-nd-48), spherical harmonic synthesis of Residual Terrain Effects on various space-air-land-sea field elements (/h-nd-49), unified computation of gravity isostatic effect integrals on land and at sea (/h-nd-50)
Approximation and modelingFortran code for all-element gravity field modeling using multi-source heterogeneous SRBFs (/h-nd-154), Fortran code for local gravity field SRBF approximation and its performance assessment (/h-nd-152), Fortran code for Molodensky boundary value correction (/h-nd-51), codes for all-element computation of Earth gravity field models (/h-nd-93)
Numerical and solution basisComputation of ultra-high-degree normalized associated Legendre functions and their derivatives (/h-nd-27, /h-nd-89), Fortran source code of the large normal-equation solution package (/h-nd-41)
Supporting algorithm documents (Downloads and Resources section): integral algorithm formulas for the disturbing gravity field in the spatial domain; theory and algorithms of spherical radial basis function gravity field approximation; principles and requirements for regional gravity field and geoid modeling, etc.
Chapter Summary The breakthrough in approximation methodology can be summarized in two sentences: it takes the “analytical relations” as the only hard constraint for fusion (hence no reduction, continuation or gridding is needed); and it treats the “multi-source heterogeneous observation system” as a joint system to be normalized (hence it can be grouped, weighted and subjected to gross error detection).
7

Paradigm Breakthrough Six: an Integrated Geodetic Reference System for a Deforming Earth

On “an Earth that is deforming at every moment”, coordinate, height, gravity and depth datums are brought into one unified, maintainable reference system.

7.1Traditional Perspective and Its Gaps

Traditional practiceGap
Established and maintained separatelyCoordinate, height and gravity datums are usually established and maintained separately
Missing dynamic consistencyAgainst the background of a deforming Earth, the dynamic consistency of the various datums lacks a scientifically rigorous system-level definition
Non-uniform updating mechanismsDatum maintenance and updating lack a unified theoretical basis and coordination mechanism

7.2Official Foresight: Definition and Core of the Integrated Reference System

Definition An integrated geodetic reference system for a deforming Earth is explicitly defined, taking the Earth that is deforming at every moment as the reference body. Its core is the nine mutually independent, uniquely invariant geodetic datum constants determined by the intrinsic properties of the Earth's gravity field — the mean center of mass of the Earth, the mean figure pole, the zero meridian, the global geopotential W₀, the geocentric gravitational constant GM and the mean Earth angular velocity ω. On that basis, and in accordance with the “four-in-one” cornerstone of geodetic theory and the requirement of spatiotemporal unity, a complete set of technical schemes is systematically expounded for the construction, realization, maintenance and updating of global and regional geodetic reference frames that integrate coordinates, height, gravity and depth.
Reference-system elementTraditional separated stateState after integration
Coordinate datumRelies on the ITRS and its conventionsPositioning and orientation are determined directly from the gravity field and incorporated into the same system of datum constants
Height datumThe starting surface and the constant suffer from “non-uniqueness”W₀ is the unique invariant datum constant and the starting surface is unified as the geoid
Gravity datumMaintained separately from the coordinate and height datumsAnalytically connected with the reference frame and the height datum through gravity field theory
Depth datumUsually defined separatelyIncorporated into a unified framework that “integrates coordinates, height, gravity and depth”

7.3The Complete Derivation Chain of the Nine Geodetic Datum Constants

ConstantConnotationRole in the reference systemNature and basis
Mean center of mass, 3 constantsThe origin of the Earth-fixed reference systemDetermines the position of the reference-system originUniquely determined by the first-degree terms of the geopotential
Mean figure pole, 2 constantsThe reference pole, the z-axis orientationDetermines the axial direction of the reference systemUniquely determined by the second-degree, first-order terms of the geopotential (the direction of the polar axis of inertia)
Zero meridian, 1 constantThe reference meridian, the x-axis orientation (the Non-Rotating Origin of the GCRS)Determines the starting meridian of the reference systemOne of the geodetic datum constants; connects with the unified theory of spatiotemporal scales
Global geopotential W₀The geoidal potentialThe unique invariant datum constant of the height datumOf conventional nature; it may be conventionally set equal to the normal geopotential on the normal ellipsoid surface, W₀ = U₀
Geocentric gravitational constant GMThe Earth's gravitational constantA basic parameter of the gravity field and the normal ellipsoidA measured quantity
Mean Earth angular velocity ωThe Earth's mean rotation rateA basic parameter of the gravity field and the normal ellipsoidA measured quantity
Official wording: these constants “are mutually statistically independent and have no analytical functional relations among them, yet are able to support the whole of geodesy”; of the four constants of the normal ellipsoid, GM and ω are measured quantities, while for the semi-major axis a and (J₂ / U₀ / flattening f) one must be agreed by convention before the other becomes measurable; geodetic constants of conventional nature should remain uniquely invariant over a long period (e.g. 20 years).

7.4The Integrated Reference System and Dynamic Datum Maintenance

StepKey point
The status of the datum constantsThe nine constants are “geodetic elements that do not vary with time” and satisfy unique invariance, precise measurability and conceptual independence from epochs and errors — they constitute “the unchanging layer” on a deforming Earth
Variation at the level of geometric realizationThe coordinates, heights and geopotential values of reference frame points vary with the Earth's deformation, so a unified dynamic frame is required: the reference value corresponds to a unique reference epoch and (non-tidal effect) epoch reduction is applied
Construction, realization, maintenance and updatingIn accordance with the “four-in-one” system and the requirement of spatiotemporal unity, frame construction and maintenance schemes are formed at both global and regional levels (the principles and technical measures of “global realization, regional construction and integrated maintenance of the vertical reference frame” given in Chapter 8 of the courseware belong to this category)
Unified spatiotemporal monitoring datumDynamic maintenance requires a unified spatiotemporal monitoring datum and reference epoch — precisely the premise of the deep fusion of multi-source heterogeneous data (see Chapter 9)

7.5Support in the Platform

Platform elementContent
Chapter 8 of the coursewareVertical datums unified in the Earth-fixed reference system: rigorous definition and scientific realization of the geodetic reference system for a deforming Earth; global realization, regional construction and integrated maintenance of the vertical reference frame (/h-nd-173.html)
Subsystem ① of ETideLoad4.5Computation of Various Tidal and Polar Shift Effects on All Geodetic Elements (including rotation polar shift effects, tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters, and Earth center of mass variation and figure pole shift effects)
Source-code modulesCodes for computing all-element rotation polar shift effects (/h-nd-56), Fortran codes for Earth center of mass variation effects (/h-nd-122), codes for forecasting ocean tidal load effects on the Earth's center of mass (/h-nd-127), Fortran codes for forecasting tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters (ERP) (/h-nd-150), codes for computing Earth ellipsoid constants (/h-nd-118)
Data and interface conventionsThe five classes of geodetic time-series data file formats and the concept of monitoring quantities (including the conventions for the scale parameters GM and the ellipsoid semi-major axis a, and for the sampling epoch), providing a unified interface for integrated monitoring
Chapter Summary The integrated reference system is the direct product of “spatiotemporal unity” among the three philosophical tenets: the constant layer is invariant, the geometric layer varies with deformation, and the frame layer is maintained by a “unique reference epoch + epoch reduction”. Thereby the four datums of coordinate, height, gravity and depth are for the first time discussed within one and the same theoretical system and one and the same technical scheme.
8

Paradigm Breakthrough Seven: Critical Inheritance and Strategic Simplification — Streamlining Theory and Improving Cognition

Using the three fundamental tenets as the criterion, redundant assumptions, approximate concepts and unnecessary complexities are streamlined with an “Occam's razor”.

8.1Methodological Attitude

This is not a wholesale rejection of tradition, but a streamlining in the manner of “Occam's razor”, with the three fundamental tenets as the criterion. The scientific purpose is to “reduce unnecessary complexity”, to return the discipline to a focus on the measurability and the mathematical-physical essence of the Earth's gravity field itself, and to make the theoretical system of physical geodesy more concise, robust and scientific.— official page /h-nd-164.html, Section 2.7
Simplification actionBasisBenefit
Discarding redundant assumptionsAny assumption that fails objective uniqueness (e.g. a definition relying on an unknown crustal density)Removes the sources of “non-uniqueness” and “multiple solutions”
De-emphasizing approximate conceptsAny intermediate surface that cannot be uniquely expressed (e.g. the telluroid and the quasi-geoid)Reduces the number of conceptual layers and the confusion among them
Simplifying unnecessary complexitiesAny treatment that can be covered by a more concise theory (e.g. the ellipsoidal complexity introduced for the spherical approximation)Algorithms and codes become more concise and verifiable

8.2Two Landmark Simplifications

Simplification propositionArgument pathBenefit
The “spherical approximation” error can be completely avoidedBy rigorously distinguishing the Earth-fixed coordinate system from the local coordinate system, it is demonstrated that the spherical approximation error inherent in traditional Earth gravity field approximation theory can be completely avoidedIt both clarifies a traditional misconception and avoids the unnecessary mathematical complexity that the introduction of ellipsoidal geodesy would bring
The Stokes boundary value theory is sufficient to solve external gravity field approximationBy introducing the Analytical Geoid, it is demonstrated that the Stokes boundary value theory is sufficient to solve the problem of external gravity field approximationIt comprehensively de-emphasizes the Molodensky boundary value theory and the complex conceptual framework it brings (the telluroid, the quasi-geoid, etc.)
Accompanying this is the reconstruction of the boundary value problem classification (see Section 6.4 of Chapter 6): according to “whether the boundary surface is an equipotential surface”, problems are divided into Stokes-type and Molodensky-type, with four approaches given.

8.3Analytical Interpretation of Terrain Effects and Their Technical Requirements: the Part that Was Streamlined and then “Legislated”

(1) There are exactly two purposes

Official Wording The first purpose is the estimation or gridding of discrete disturbing gravity field quantities, so as to facilitate numerical spatial-domain gravity field integral computation or gravity exploration modeling; the other purpose is the separation of the ultra-short-wavelength components of gravity field quantities during gravity field approximation, so as to improve the approximation performance for the ultra-short-wavelength gravity field.
No.Key elementClassification examples
①Terrain or crustal mass adjustment methodLocal Terrain Effect, Terrain Bouguer Effect, Seawater Bouguer Effect, Isostatic Effect, Helmert Condensation Effect, Residual Terrain Effect, etc.
②Type of gravity field quantity (the object of the terrain effect)Height anomalies, gravity disturbances, vertical deflections, gravity gradients, etc.
③Position of the gravity field quantityGround gravity disturbances, gravity disturbances external to the Earth, gravity disturbances on the geoid, etc.
The three classes of elements combine into 3 × 3 = 9 different terrain effect quantities; PAGravf4.5 distinguishes them strictly so as to avoid calling the wrong program.

(2) Four quantitative selection criteria

No.CriterionTestStatus
①Smoothness criterionTo improve the accuracy of estimating or gridding discrete observed disturbing field quantities, the standard deviation of the discrete field quantities after removing the terrain effects should decreaseA technical requirement, globally applicable
②Ultra-short-wavelength criterionThe standard deviation of the disturbing field quantities decreases after the terrain effects are removed, and the mean value of the terrain effect quantity over tens of kilometres is very small and can be neglectedA technical requirement
③Outlier criterionThe ratio D/ε of the range D to the standard deviation ε reflects the outlying character of the ultra-short-wavelength signal; a large D/ε means that the ultra-short-wavelength signal has a small share but a large magnitude, so using that terrain effect to process that field quantity is advantageousA technical reference, to be applied flexibly
④Short-wavelength richness criterionWhen the D/ε magnitudes of several terrain effects are comparable, the larger the ratio of the standard deviation of the gravity terrain effect to that of the height anomaly terrain effect, the richer the short-wavelength components of that terrain effectA technical reference, to be applied flexibly
Official note: when gravity data are so scarce that the spatial representativeness of the statistical results is seriously insufficient, these criteria no longer apply; the four criteria express only basic concepts, and for specific problems the methods, algorithms and technical schemes should be refined around those concepts.

(3) The remove-restore method and its two restrictive requirements

StepContent
The basic three-step scheme① Compute and remove the terrain effect of the source field quantity to obtain the residual value of the source field quantity; ② from the residual value, solve for the residual value of the target field element by the approximation method; ③ compute and restore the terrain effect of the target field element to obtain the approximation solution
Prior recognitionTerrain mass density is a typical geophysical element, so the computation of terrain effects always contains uncertainty due to density uncertainty; therefore a terrain effect of any nature on any gravity field quantity fails to satisfy the requirements of uniqueness and measurability and cannot become a valid geodetic requirement
Restrictive requirement oneThe terrain mass model (including its adjustment method) and the integration radius used for computing the terrain effect of the source field quantity and that of the target field element must be exactly the same
Restrictive requirement twoThe terrain effect algorithm for the source field quantity and that for the target field element must be fully analytically compatible: their analytical functional relation must be exactly the same as the analytical functional relation between the source field quantity and the target field element
Official emphasis: if either requirement is not satisfied, the approximation result will contain uncontrollable uncertainty, degrading the approximation performance and the quality control capability.

(4) Role and performance-control principles

No.Principle
①A terrain effect of any nature on any type of gravity field quantity can never independently serve as an observation field quantity for gravity field approximation — a restrictive requirement that must be strictly observed
②Through the remove-restore method, using the current observation field quantities as constraints and control, approximation methods can be used to improve the resolution or observation type and construct densified observation field quantities containing terrain ultra-short-wavelength information
③Keep the approximation (parameterized) observation model of the current observation field quantities unchanged (a binding requirement), supplement it with densified observation field quantity models and markedly reduce their sensitivity to the parameters, so as to achieve ultra-high-resolution gravity field approximation by least squares
④The cumulative residual gravity field approximation technique can be used to improve the approximation performance for the ultra-short-wavelength gravity field
Official special note: at a time when Earth gravity field exploration technology is developing rapidly and observation resources are becoming ever richer, “it is unscientific to overstate the role and position of terrain effects in gravity field approximation without thorough and meticulous testing and analysis and without concrete evidence”.

8.4The Hard Constraint Retained after Streamlining: Analytical Compatibility

Definition Analytical Compatibility is the concrete manifestation of geodetic theory and of the uniqueness of the monitored object, and it is the minimum requirement for the deep fusion of multi-source heterogeneous data and the collaborative monitoring of diverse heterogeneous techniques.
ClassObjectExample
Class 1: theoretically binding requirementCompatibility between different types of geodetic observables or parameters and same-type geodynamic influence quantitiesThe load effect on the height anomaly equals the Hotine integral of the load effect on gravity disturbances; the solid Earth tidal effect on the normal height at a station equals the difference between the solid Earth tidal effects on its ellipsoidal height and on the geoid
Class 2: determined by dynamicsCompatibility between same-type observables or parameters and different types of geodynamic influence quantitiesDetermined by the geodynamic equations of a deforming Earth (including the constitutive equations)

8.5Simplification Is Not Weakening: Three Retained Lines

De-emphasizedRetained and reinforcedReason
The complex conceptual framework of Molodensky (the telluroid, the quasi-geoid, etc.)The Stokes-type solution system (regularized Stokes integral, Hotine integral, Vening-Meinesz integral, radial gradient integral, etc.)The latter is already sufficient to solve external gravity field approximation and completely avoids the terrain condensation problem
The mathematical complexity brought by ellipsoidal geodesyThe rigorous distinction between the Earth-fixed coordinate system and the local coordinate systemThe spherical approximation error can be completely avoided; there is no need to trade mathematical complexity for rigour
Generalized use of terrain effectsThe four criteria for terrain effects, the two restrictive requirements, the four performance-control principles, and Analytical CompatibilityTerrain effects still have two irreplaceable purposes, but they must be constrained by the criteria and restrictions
Chapter Summary This chapter embodies an academic attitude of “doing subtraction”: whatever conventions, assumptions and concepts cannot be supported by measurable physical quantities are stripped away as far as possible; whatever is retained must be able to pass tests by analytical relations and by measurement. This is precisely the “purification” that must be completed before the platform writes theory into code.
9

Geodesy for a Deforming Earth: the Academic Thought System of the Time-Variable Branch

Elevating “deformation” from a correction term to a central disciplinary subject, and turning time-variable problems into solvable problems through “mathematical isomorphism”.

9.1Disciplinary Concept: Geodesy for a Deforming Earth

Geodesy for a Deforming Earth (not merely “Deformation geodesy”) is a modern geodesy whose objects of observation and study are the deforming Earth's physical body and Earth-fixed space; it is likewise a metrological science for the precise measurement of the Earth and the monitoring of global change.— ZHANG Chuanyin, 2025, Geodesy for a Deforming Earth, Chinese Science Press (quoted on official page /Tide.html)
Why Stress That It Is “Not Merely Deformation Geodesy” It does not “study deformation” on a static Earth; rather, it acknowledges that the Earth is deforming at every moment, and on that basis it rebuilds the observed objects, the reference frames, datum maintenance and the concept of error: the steady state is only a special case of the time-variable, and the dynamic frame is the default form. This is precisely the theoretical root of ETideLoad4.5's coverage of tidal and non-tidal effects, time series analysis, load deformation field approximation, CORS-network and InSAR synergy, and ground stability computation.

9.2The Pivotal Proposition: “Mathematical Isomorphism”

Earth's gravity field (steady state)Load deformation field / time-varying gravity field (time-variable)
The analytical relations between gravity field parametersThe analytical relations between the load effects on gravity field parameters are entirely consistent with them
The global gravity field is represented by a Geopotential Coefficient Model (GCM); given the coefficients, the gravity field parameters at any external point can be computed; the geoid is computed from gravity data by the Stokes integralThe global load deformation field and the time-varying gravity field are represented by a Global Surface Load Spherical Harmonic Coefficient Model; given the load spherical harmonic coefficients, the load effects on the various elements external to the solid Earth can be computed; surface environmental load effects are computed from their load equivalent water height by the Green's function integral
The approximation theory is linear and can be approximated by the remove-restore scheme and the cumulative iteration methodThe elastic (linear viscoelastic) load deformation theory is likewise linear and can equally be refined by the remove-restore scheme and cumulative approximation
The methods are summarized as spatial-domain boundary value problem integral methods and spectral-domain spherical basis function (surface spherical functions, radial basis functions, spline functions, etc.) approximation methodsFor load deformation field (time-varying gravity field) approximation or monitoring there are likewise two methods: the load Green's function integral constraint and spectral-domain spherical basis function approximation
An easy-to-remember corollary: the sum of the deformation effects of various environmental loads (atmospheric pressure, terrestrial water, sea level variations, etc.) equals the deformation effect of the sum of those loads.

9.3Three Forms of Ground Vertical Deformation and Their Spatiotemporal Dynamic Quantitative Characteristics

FormMechanismSpatiotemporal dynamic quantitative characteristics
Elastic load-induced vertical deformationExcited by mass variations of surface environmental loads, it causes changes in the Earth's geopotential (direct effect) and, through the elastic dynamic action of the solid Earth, leads to deformation (indirect effect, characterized by load Love numbers)Within the monitoring area it manifests as ground vertical deformation and gravity field variations synchronous in time with the load variations; the time-varying characteristics resemble those of surface environmental load variations, displaying complex nonlinearity and quasi-periodicity
Plastic isostatic vertical deformationAfter environmental geological dynamic action disrupts the original equilibrium of the subsurface rock and soil, the rock and soil slowly tend towards another equilibrium state under their own gravity or internal stress (e.g. compaction after water loss and expansion after water seepage/injection in underground voids, deformation of the surrounding rock caused by underground engineering construction, and plastic rebound of the ground after surface mass migration)Spatial domain: the dynamic action point lies inside the subsurface rock and soil, the spatial influence angle is about 45°, and the radius of spatial influence of ground deformation is approximately equal to the burial depth of the subsurface action point. Time domain: the adjustment duration is approximately proportional to the burial depth; on a scale of several years the deformation quantity and its acceleration rate have opposite signs, while within several months the variation is short-term linear
Local tectonic vertical deformationDriven by the horizontal motion of plates and acting only near compressional fault zonesThe magnitude of deformation decays rapidly to zero with distance from the fault zone, and the radius of spatial influence is comparable to the tectonic depth; on a centennial timescale the deformation rate remains essentially constant
The official site groups the latter two under the collective term “non-load vertical deformation”, both belonging to plastic deformation.

9.4Principles of Deep Fusion of Multi-Source Heterogeneous Data and Collaboration of Diverse Heterogeneous Techniques (Five Principles)

No.Principle (key points of the official wording)Methodological implication
1Construct scientifically consistent geophysical models, rigorously uniform numerical standards and analytically compatible geodetic and geodynamic algorithms, and unify the spatiotemporal monitoring datum and reference epoch, so as to create the mathematical-physical environment for collaborative monitoring by multiple geodetic techniques in space, air, land and seaThe premise of fusion is the unification of models and standards
2On the principles of geophysical geodesy, deeply fuse or constrain-assimilate multi-source heterogeneous geodetic data; through the assimilation of diverse heterogeneous geodetic observations, reconstruct the geodetic and geodynamic spatiotemporal correlations among the various monitoring quantities, realizing collaborative monitoring across diverse heterogeneous geometric and physical geodetic techniquesReconstruction of spatiotemporal correlations replaces post hoc stitching
3For time series of same-type multi-source heterogeneous monitoring quantities, achieve deep epoch-by-epoch fusion through fundamental geodetic constraints or joint measurement adjustment (with additional monitoring datum parameters as required)The unit of fusion for same-type quantities is the “epoch”
4For time series of multiple monitoring quantities of different types, achieve deep analytical fusion through constraints from physical geodesy, solid Earth geophysics or environmental geodynamics (with additional dynamic parameters as required)The fusion of heterogeneous quantities rests on “dynamic constraints”
5Through the deep fusion of multi-source heterogeneous data and the collaborative monitoring of diverse heterogeneous techniques, simultaneously improve the spatiotemporal resolution of monitoring and enrich the variety of monitored elements, reveal the geophysical structure and dynamic characteristics of the monitored objects, and scientifically support the large-scale, intelligent and automated observation of the EarthThe acceptance standard is the simultaneous improvement of resolution, elements and mechanisms

9.5Principle of Collaborative Monitoring by a CORS Network and Time-Series InSAR (Three Principles)

No.Principle
1Through gross error detection, spatial filtering and time-series analysis, the time-series InSAR monitoring quantities are separated into two parts — the vertical variations of the soil within a few metres of the ground surface (expansion and contraction caused by temperature and precipitation) together with the ground surface, and the vertical deformation of the rock and soil layers at depths of several metres; only the latter is compatible with other geodetic monitoring
2The ellipsoidal height variation time series of the CORS network constrain the multi-source time-series InSAR monitoring quantities and control the precise separation of the vertical deformation signal within them
3Only the vertical deformation of rock and soil layers at depths of several metres is the information required for monitoring ground subsidence, seismic and geological environmental hazards, ground stability variations, solid Earth deformation, groundwater and geodynamics; the separated vertical variations of the ground surface and shallow soil can be used for soil, wetland and water environment monitoring, as well as geological environment survey monitoring, disaster monitoring and post-disaster assessment, and hydro-meteorological research

9.6Seamless Continuous Quantitative Monitoring of Regional Ground Stability Variations (Three Items)

No.Content
1Based on the grid time series of ground vertical deformation, gravity and tilt variations fused from multi-source heterogeneous geodetic data, deterministic criteria for ground stability degradation are constructed, realizing seamless quantitative continuous monitoring of regional ground stability variations
2Quantitative criteria for ground stability degradation (deterministic objective natural regularities): an increase in ground ellipsoidal height / a decrease in gravity; large horizontal gradients of ellipsoidal height or gravity variations; a large inner product of the tilt variation with the terrain slope, etc.
3With reference to geological hazard events that have occurred, the ground stability variation grid time series estimated from various geodetic monitoring quantities are optimized and integrated, building a stability variation grid time series adapted to the local environmental geology

9.7Scientific Objectives and Three Technical Features of ETideLoad4.5

Employing consistent geophysical models and identical numerical standards, it constructs compatible geodetic and geodynamic algorithms and uniformly computes the various tidal and non-tidal effects on geodetic elements; from surface environmental observations it precisely approximates global and regional load deformation fields; strictly following the principles of geodesy and solid Earth dynamics it constrains and assimilates the deep fusion of multi-source heterogeneous monitoring data, realizes the collaborative monitoring of terrestrial water, the load deformation field and the time-varying gravity field, and quantitatively tracks variations in the surface dynamic environment and ground stability.— official page /Tide.html
No.Technical feature
1Strictly adopting scientifically unified standards and analytically compatible algorithms, it precisely computes the solid Earth, ocean and atmospheric tidal load effects, polar shift effects, Earth center of mass variation effects and permanent tide effects on all geodetic elements on the ground and external to the solid Earth, realizing global forecasting of all kinds of tidal effects on all geodetic elements on the ground
2It precisely computes the non-tidal surface environmental load deformation field and the time-varying gravity field for the atmosphere, sea level, soil moisture, river-lake-reservoir water and glaciers and snow; on the basis of geodetic and solid Earth deformation theory it constrains and assimilates the deep fusion of various geodetic monitoring quantities with surface environmental data, and collaboratively monitors terrestrial water variations and the time-varying gravity field
3It builds a regionally unified, long-term stable spatiotemporal monitoring datum and fuses CORS networks, InSAR and multi-source geodetic data; following objective natural regularities it constructs quantitative identification criteria for ground stability from the time series of geodetic geometric and physical fields, realizing spatially seamless and temporally continuous quantitative monitoring and short-term prediction of ground stability variations
Chapter Summary The academic thought of the time-variable branch can be summarized in three steps: acknowledge that deformation is a central disciplinary subject (tidal deformation and non-tidal deformation); use the isomorphic relation to turn the time-variable into the solvable (load deformation field = time-varying gravity field); and use a unified datum and analytical constraints to turn multi-technique collaboration into the computable (the five fusion principles plus collaborative monitoring and stability criteria).
10

Error and Quality-Control Philosophy, and the Algorithm / Source-Code Lineage

Converting “accuracy” from a customary expression into a conceptual system with definite objects, computable values and verifiable results.

10.1Core Conceptual Update: Spatial Representativeness Error and Spatial Representativeness Accuracy

Two Key Definitions Earth gravity field quantities are continuous and differentiable in the external space of the Earth or on a boundary surface; hence, in the mathematical model of gravity field approximation, what actually functions is the spatial average of the observed field quantity corresponding to a certain resolution. Therefore: the error of an observed gravity field quantity refers specifically to the error of the spatial average of that quantity at a given spatial resolution — the Spatial Representativeness Error — and not the actual observation error at the measuring point; and the accuracy of a target field element used to express the approximation solution refers specifically to the Spatial Representativeness Accuracy at the effective resolution, not a point-value accuracy. In the era of terrestrial geodesy it was usually assumed that the short- and ultra-short-wavelength structure was related to topographic relief, so the Spatial Representativeness Error was also called the “terrain representativeness error”.
QuestionOfficial conclusion
On what does the Spatial Representativeness Error of an observed field quantity depend?It depends on the observation error, the spatial density of measuring points and the local spatial structure of the gravity field; when the observation accuracy is sufficient, it is mainly determined by the density of measuring points and the local gravity field structure
The criterion of “accuracy saturation”When the gravity measurement accuracy at measuring points is better than 0.1 mGal and the Spatial Representativeness Error of 1′×1′ gravity disturbances is 1 mGal, the Spatial Representativeness Error is mainly determined by the density of measuring points, the local gravity field structure and the performance of the gridding algorithm; at this point, further improving the gravity measurement accuracy at measuring points is ineffective for improving the Spatial Representativeness Error of the observed gravity disturbances
The nature of spatial resolutionThe spatial resolution of a gravity field quantity is not a simple geometric image pixel average; its representativeness is related to the local gravity field structure: the same resolution is more representative in areas with a simple gravity field structure and less representative in complex areas; any grid of gravity field quantities at a given resolution contains rich spatial analytical functional relations between cells, and the gravity field information it contains is far richer than the geometric resolution suggests
The “high analyticity” of gravity field informationGravity field approximation is essentially a one-dimensional linear transformation with one degree of freedom in a linear gravity field space, in which field quantities at different positions and of different types are functionally correlated; precisely for this reason, weak gravity field signals can be effectively extracted from strongly noisy observation environments — for example, satellite gravity exploration can effectively extract gravity field signals from a strongly noisy environment with a signal-to-noise ratio below 10⁻³

10.2Three Schemes for Error Analysis and Accuracy Assessment

SchemeSteps
Spatial-domain integral method · Scheme I① Estimate the Spatial Representativeness Error of the integrand observation field quantity grid on the boundary surface (including the various errors introduced in obtaining the grid from actual discrete observations); ② derive the error propagation formula from the gravity field integral formula, neglect the influence of the reference gravity field model error, and estimate the Spatial Representativeness Accuracy of the target field element
Spatial-domain integral method · Scheme II① Construct a gravity field integral algorithm that takes the target field element as the integrand quantity, the surface on which the target field element lies as the boundary surface, and the actual observed field quantities as the integrand values; ② compute by the integral method the integral values of the observed field quantities at the measuring points, statistically analyse the differences between the integral values and the measured values, and obtain the Spatial Representativeness Error of the observed field quantities; ③ estimate the Spatial Representativeness Accuracy of the target field element by Scheme I
Spectral-domain least squares approximation① From the estimated spectral-domain coefficients obtained by approximation (geopotential coefficients or SRBF coefficients), compute by the spectral-domain series expansion the estimated value of each observed field quantity at the measuring points, and statistically analyse the differences from the measured values to obtain the Spatial Representativeness Error of each observed field quantity; ② derive the error propagation algorithm formula from the mathematical model of spectral-domain least squares gravity field approximation; ③ compute the accuracy of all spectral-domain coefficients and the Spatial Representativeness Accuracy of the target field element
Official conclusion: using gravity field approximation methods, the Spatial Representativeness Error of observed gravity field quantities of any type from space, air, land and sea can be effectively determined, yet the direct measurement accuracy specifications of measuring instruments cannot; although gravity field approximation methods can only give an upper bound for the actual instrument measurement error, the decisive factor for the level of gravity field modeling can only be the Spatial Representativeness Error of the observed field quantities.

10.3The Lineage of Quality-Control Measures

MeasureUseOfficial-site basis
Self-testing with an ultra-high-degree modelTaking degrees 1–540 of EGM2008 as the reference gravity field and degrees 541–1800 as the residual disturbing gravity field, the “model-value comparison method” is used to test the technical performance of approximation programs and parameter settings/Geoid.html, “algorithmic route optimization”
Closed-loop operationFrom one type of field element, all-element field elements in the whole external space can be computed, and the same type of field element at the same point can be computed cyclically; differences and similarities are compared to analyse the algorithmic characteristics/Geoid.html
Error simulationBecause approximation theory is based on a linear space, simulated spatial noise can be used as observations (or as land-sea terrain) input, so that the output directly expresses the error distribution properties of the target field elements (or terrain effects)/h-col-105.html, /Geoid.html
Gross error detection and system weight controlWithin the spectral-domain least squares framework, the weight of the corresponding observation coefficient is set to 0 to realize gross error detection and external accuracy assessment; the system weight is set greater than 1 to analytically fuse very few high-precision data sets/Geoid.html
Statistical selection of terrain effect typesAccording to the four quantitative selection criteria, various terrain effects are statistically compared and the most advantageous type is selected/h-nd-163.html
Quasi-stable adjustmentQuasi-stable adjustment of control networks based on monitoring quantities (/h-nd-75)Source Codes section
Gridding and filteringWeighted basis-function gridding of multi-source heterogeneous unevenly distributed data (/h-nd-76), low-pass filtering of digital grid data (/h-nd-77), first- and second-order horizontal gradient estimation for grid values (/h-nd-31, /h-nd-32)Source Codes section
Basic solution and interpolationFortran source code of the large normal-equation solution package (/h-nd-41), Fortran source code of the one-dimensional interpolation package for irregularly sampled data (/h-nd-42)Source Codes section

10.4Algorithm and Source-Code Lineage of the Two Systems (Grouped Overview)

GroupRepresentative modules (official source-code section pages)
Geodetic foundationsGeodetic coordinate transformation package (39), geodetic time system conversion package (40), one-dimensional interpolation package for irregularly sampled data (42), large normal-equation solution package (41)
Normal gravity field and spherical harmonicsComputation of normal Earth gravity field parameters (24), computation of Legendre functions and their derivatives (25), computation of even-degree normal gravity potential coefficients (26), computation of ultra-high-degree normalized associated Legendre functions and their derivatives (27, 89)
Terrain effects and mass adjustmentRigorous integration of Local Terrain Effects (124), Helmert condensation integration (47), rigorous integration of land-sea Complete Bouguer effects (48), spherical harmonic synthesis of Residual Terrain Effects on various space-air-land-sea field elements (49), unified computation of gravity isostatic effect integrals on land and at sea (50)
Boundary value problems and integral operationsPoisson integral for various field elements external to the Earth (69), radial gradient numerical integration (68), disturbing gravity gradient integration (72), inverse integral operation for disturbing gravity (73), inverse Stokes/Hotine/Vening-Meinesz operations (66), inversion of other disturbing field elements from the height anomaly (67), generalized Stokes/Hotine integrals (94), Molodensky boundary value correction (51)
Gravity field modelingAll-element computation of Earth gravity field models (93), all-element gravity field modeling with multi-source heterogeneous SRBFs (154), local gravity field SRBF approximation and its performance assessment (152)
Tides and rotationAll-element solid Earth tidal effects (57), all-element rotation polar shift effects (56), all-element computation of the permanent tide on the ground (61), solid Earth tidal / ocean tidal / atmospheric tidal / non-tidal load perturbations of Earth satellite orbits (58, 59, 60, 64)
Load tides and load deformationDirect effect of ocean tidal loads on the Earth's geopotential coefficients (43), spherical harmonic synthesis of ocean tidal load effects (44), direct effect of atmospheric pressure tides on the Earth's geopotential coefficients (45), building of load spherical harmonic coefficient model time series (62), all-element spherical harmonic synthesis of load effects (63), numerical computation of regional load Green's functions (70), all-element geodetic computation of the load deformation field by Green's integral (71), load deformation effects by SRBF approximation (135), land water and load deformation time series by Green's integral (144), land water and load deformation field time series by SRBF (146)
Spatiotemporal datums and monitoringComputation of Earth ellipsoid constants (118), Earth center of mass variation effects (122), forecasting of ocean tidal load effects on the Earth's center of mass (127), forecasting of tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters (150), quantitative computation of ground stability variations from vertical deformation grids (74)
Height datum applicationsComputing the radial variation rate of the height anomaly from a gravity field model (78), computing the difference between orthometric and normal heights (79), computing geopotential differences and ellipsoidal height differences between orthometric (normal) equi-height surfaces (80), construction of a model gravity equipotential surface through a specified point (81)
The numbers in brackets are official page identifiers (of the form /h-nd-39.html); the list is continuously updated as the official site uploads new material.

10.5Correspondence between the Ten Subsystems and the Academic Threads

PAGravf4.5 (steady-state branch)ETideLoad4.5 (time-variable branch)
① Analysis and Preprocessing of Earth Gravity Field Data① Computation of Various Tidal and Polar Shift Effects on All Geodetic Elements
② Computation of Diverse Terrain Effects on Various Gravity Field Elements② Processing and Analysis of Non-Tidal Geodetic Variation Time Series
③ High-Precision Gravity Field Approximation and Full-Element Modeling③ Load Deformation Field Approximation and Monitoring from Heterogeneous Variations
④ Optimization, Unification, and Application of Regional Height Datums④ CORS/InSAR Collaborative Monitoring and Ground Stability Estimation
⑤ Toolkit for Geodetic Data File Editing, Calculation, and Visualization⑤ Editing, Calculation and Visualization of Geodetic Data
Subsystem names are taken verbatim from official pages /Geoid.html and /Tide.html. The correspondence is: ①②③ carry the “algorithms and modeling” thread, ④ carries the “datum and stability” thread, and ⑤ provides support for “data consistency and visualization”.
Chapter Summary The error and quality-control philosophy turns “accuracy” into three operational components: the definition (spatial representativeness), the objects (observed field quantities / target field elements / spectral coefficients), and the algorithms (the three schemes). The lineage of measures (model self-testing, closed-loop operation, error simulation, gross error detection, quasi-stable adjustment, gridding and filtering) allows this theory to be applied directly in computation workflows.
11

Realization and Dissemination of the Academic Thought: Source Codes, Courseware, Monographs, Papers and Open Sharing

How the last three segments of the “original theory – rigorous algorithms – independent software – validation and application” closed loop are put into practice.

11.1Technical Foundation and Program Scale

DimensionOfficial wording
Development approachDeveloped in the Visual Studio 2017 x64 integrated environment using code-level hybrid programming: QT C++ (Visual C++) for the interface, Intel Fortran for the core function modules, and mathGL C++ for data visualization
Program scalePAGravf4.5 comprises nearly 50 win64 programs and more than 500 function modules; ETideLoad4.5 comprises more than 50 win64 programs and more than 600 function modules
Example mechanismBoth packages are provided with complete computation examples; each program example folder contains the operation process, input-output data and a series of program interface screenshots; after completing all the example exercises (about 7 working days per package), users are basically able to use the software system independently
Operating requirementsWindows 10 platform; the split-volume files (.exe and .2) must be downloaded into the same folder before installation

11.2Open Source Codes: a “Recomputable” Commitment Module by Module

ItemContent
Mode of openingThe Intel Fortran source codes of both software packages are refined, integrated and tested module by module, and are uploaded successively for free download; the modules are relatively independent and easy to call
Elements of a module introductionModule name, basic functions, geophysical model, DOS test program code, module source code, calling-module source code, algorithm formulas
VerifiabilityEach module provides its algorithm formulas, geophysical model and a runnable test program, so that propositions such as Analytical Compatibility, the restrictive requirements and the Spatial Representativeness Error can be independently recomputed and reviewed at module level
Entry pointsThe official “Fortran Codes” section /h-col-110.html and its module pages; the “Source Codes” category is listed at /h-nr--0_31_5.html

11.3The Teaching System: Nine Courseware Decks and 48 Class Hours

CoursewareAcademic topicOfficial page
Introduction [Review]Disciplinary concepts, tasks and course framework/h-nd-166.html
Chapter 1: Basic theory of the Earth's gravity fieldThe gravity field as the common physical foundation of theory and application/h-nd-166.html
Chapter 2: Geodetic methods for the Earth's gravity fieldOfficial wording: since the 1950s terrestrial gravity measurement has developed rapidly, satellite orbit observations have provided a global understanding of the gravity field, satellite altimetry has acquired a high-resolution global marine gravity field, shipborne and airborne gravity have provided efficient means for regional surveys, and satellite-to-satellite tracking and satellite gravity gradiometry have rapidly acquired a high-precision global gravity field and its time-variable information; a landscape of multi-type, multi-scale gravity field information acquisition from the ground, ocean, air and space has now taken shape/h-nd-167.html
Chapter 3: Terrain effects, tidal and load effectsThe common origin of the three classes of effects and their unified treatment; unified treatment is a binding principle and restrictive requirement of physical geodesy/h-nd-168.html
Chapter 4: Gravity field-determined theory of the terrestrial reference frameUnification of the Earth-fixed reference system with relativistic geodesy in Earth space/h-nd-169.html
Chapter 5: Gravity field approximation from heterogeneous observationsSolving the external gravity field and its time-variable part by combining many types of data that are diverse in spatial distribution, unordered in observation time and limited in observation resources/h-nd-170.html
Chapter 6: Height datums and their gravity field theoryDatum constants, the starting surface and height systems/h-nd-171.html
Chapter 7: All-element modeling of the local gravity field and time-variable monitoringRelying on PAGravf4.5 and ETideLoad4.5, it explains the technical key points, computation workflows and quality-control measures/h-nd-172.html
Chapter 8: Vertical datums unified in the Earth-fixed reference systemRigorous definition and scientific realization of the geodetic reference system for a deforming Earth; global realization, regional construction and integrated maintenance of the vertical reference frame/h-nd-173.html
Official page /h-nd-166.html states that, using Physical Geodesy (ZHANG Chuanyin, 2026, Science Press) as the textbook, a complete set of classroom teaching courseware has been prepared; 48 class hours are recommended for undergraduate teaching, with one complete PPT for each chapter, including an introduction PPT — nine PPT decks in total.

11.4Monographs and Theoretical Papers

BookRelation to the platform and the academic thought
Geodesy for a Deforming Earth (ZHANG Chuanyin, 2025, Science Press; Geodesy and Geodynamics Series, edited by Academician SUN Heping)Companion to ETideLoad4.5; it provides the theoretical basis of the time-variable branch, including the concept of geodesy for a deforming Earth and the rigorous redefinition and scientific realization of the terrestrial reference frame (Chapter 7)
Physical Geodesy (ZHANG Chuanyin, 2026, Science Press)The textbook foundation of PAGravf4.5; its content summary is precisely the outline of the paradigm innovation and the seven breakthroughs cited in the master guideline of this report
Theoretical paper (official page)Contribution to the academic thought
Monitoring method for the joint determination of the Earth's center of mass, the figure pole and various Earth rotation dynamic parameters (/h-nd-160)Conversion of the gravity field-determined reference-frame theory into observables and monitoring models (published in Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica)
Theoretical foundation of the height datum gravity field unified in the Earth-fixed reference system and updating of classical concepts (/h-nd-161)Height datum theory and the updating of classical concepts (the official site notes open discussion and open debate)
Error analysis and accuracy assessment in PAGravf gravity field approximation (/h-nd-162)The Spatial Representativeness Error and the three accuracy analysis schemes
Principles, methods and restrictive requirements for terrain effects on PAGravf gravity field quantities (/h-nd-163)The two purposes of terrain effects, the four criteria, the two restrictive requirements and the performance-control principles
Geoid accuracy assessment method based on GNSS/leveling and the gravity field error characteristics (/h-nd-84)An element-based method for expressing the accuracy of level surface results
CORS network ground stability variation monitoring and prediction (/h-nd-87)The quantitative criteria for ground stability and the engineering validation of numerical hazard prediction
Introduction to the Earth Tide, Load Effect and Deformation Monitoring Computation system (/h-nd-91)Report at the 2021 International Forum on Earth System Space Monitoring (hosted by the Southern University of Science and Technology), with the ETideLoad courseware attached
The current state of research on solid Earth tides (/h-nd-82)The research thread of solid Earth tides, internal Earth structure, rotation and liquid-core response
Geodetic software, a key to university education (/h-nd-83)The role of hands-on software in university education: intuitive understanding and phenomenon simulation
Refinement of the gravity field and geoid in China's coastal zone and sea areas (/h-nd-23)An early engineering practice of the reference-frame and height datum theories in the coastal zone
Articles are categorized as “News / Software Teaching / Work Processes / Source Codes”; the index is at /h-nr.html and its pages. All source-code pages are listed at /h-col-110.html.

11.5Open Sharing and Accessible Resources (Downloads and Resources Section)

The platform was independently developed over a decade by the team of Prof. ZHANG Chuanyin of the Chinese Academy of Surveying and Mapping, integrating more than twenty years of research results; its two systems respectively play the roles of the “gravity field engine” and the “deformation effect processor”; the platform and its core source codes have been open-sourced and made freely accessible since September 2021.

The platform and its core source codes have been open-sourced and made freely accessible since September 2021, in order to improve the science-education environment in which such computational resources have been critically scarce worldwide, to build a cognitive concept and knowledge system for the fusion of multi-source heterogeneous geodetic data and the collaboration of diverse heterogeneous techniques, to display the charm and potential of geodesy, and to drive the strategic transformation of the geodetic discipline from “technical data service” to “Earth system analysis” and of geodetic education from “technology-oriented” knowledge transfer to “problem-driven” systems thinking and conceptual innovation.— platform positioning paragraph of the official-site home page
ResourceContent
Software and referencesThe main program packages and User References of PAGravf4.5 and ETideLoad4.5; additionally the JPLEPH.440 planetary ephemeris file required by ETideLoad
Algorithm and process documentsTen topical documents for each of the two systems (the terrain effect algorithmic framework; integral algorithms for the disturbing gravity field in the spatial domain; spherical radial basis function approximation; principles of regional gravity field and geoid modeling; unified computation of solid Earth tidal effects on all elements on the ground and external to the solid Earth; global load tide harmonic analysis and spherical harmonic synthesis; rotation polar shift and tidal effects on Earth rotation parameters; Earth center of mass variation and figure pole shifts; global load spherical harmonic analysis and spherical harmonic synthesis of the load deformation field; load Green's functions and spatial-domain integrals; SRBF approximation of surface loads; radial basis function approximation of the load deformation field from multi-source heterogeneous monitoring quantities, etc.)
Computation workflows and exercisesTerrain effects and gravity exploration modeling exercise; the expedited process for all-element gravity field modeling in full external space using SRBFs; the complete computation process of high-resolution surface load deformation field time series; the collaborative monitoring process of groundwater and surface environmental load deformation field; the expedited process for computing land-sea Bouguer and isostatic anomalies from a gravity field model, etc.
External data resources (list of links)ICGEM (gravity field models), ISG (regional geoid models and software), DTU (gravity field / ocean tide models), GRACE / GRACE-FO / AOD1B / PODAAC / CSR (satellite gravity), IERS (conventions and EOP), GGFC (loading and angular momentum), SOFA (fundamental astronomy library), ITRF2014, ETOPO / GEBCO / SRTM / Sandwell (topography and bathymetry), GLDAS / CPC (hydrology and meteorology), OpenADB / Aviso / CMEMS (sea level and ocean), TPXO / DTU ocean tide models, SHTOOLS (spherical harmonic analysis library), Chalmers ocean tide loading online service
Intended readershipIntegrating classroom instruction, self-study exercises, applied computing and scientific research; suitable for senior undergraduates, graduate students, scientific researchers and engineering technicians in geodesy and geosciences, geology and geophysics, geomatics and geographic information, aerospace and satellite dynamics, and seismology and geodynamics

11.6Academic Heritage and Academic Exchange

ItemContent (as stated in the official articles)
Academic lineageThe official site has memorial pages: “In deep remembrance of the eminent geodesist and geophysicist Academician XU Houze — progressing continuously under his teaching, encouragement and care” (/h-nd-85) and “Eternal glory, enduring merit; the uncrowned master Prof. CHAO Dingbo lives forever” (/h-nd-86). These articles record that the author was introduced to the field of surveying and mapping by Prof. ZHANG Zhenglu, and in 1998 became a doctoral student under Prof. CHAO Dingbo, entering the fields of the gravity field and geodynamics; over the years he exchanged views at length with his predecessors on themes such as “the gravimetric geoid and boundary value problems, the global geopotential W₀ and the definition of the geoid, all-element polar shift effects and tidal datums in geodesy, height systems and their applicability, solid Earth tides and the load deformation field, and geodetic monitoring of geological environmental hazards”
Academic exchange mechanismsThe official site provides an “online message board” for open discussion (/h-msgBoard.html); theoretical paper pages note open discussion, open debate and academic exchange in the message board; the sections are categorized as “News / Software Teaching / Work Processes / Source Codes” for easy retrieval
Significance of the academic heritageThe articles show that several propositions expounded in this report (W₀ and the definition of the geoid, polar shift and tidal datums, the applicability of height systems, solid Earth tides and the load deformation field, and monitoring of geological environmental hazards) were already discussed at length during the author's academic development, so this body of academic thought has a clear academic thread
The content of this subsection is quoted from the official article pages; the persons, dates and themes follow the wording of the official site.
Chapter Summary The way the academic thought is disseminated is as verifiable as its content: source codes support recomputation, courseware supports teaching, monographs and papers support citation, and the message board supports debate; and since September 2021 open sharing has handed the right of verification to users — precisely the manifestation of the “principle of precise measurability” at the level of academic dissemination.
12

Engineering Validation, Academic Contributions and Outlook

Gathering the foregoing thought into four lines — innovation closed loop, engineering validation, contributions, and what remains to be developed — and giving the official pages on which they rest.

12.1The Innovation Closed Loop and the Division of Labour between the Two Systems

Closed-loop stageContent
Original theoryThe three philosophical tenets and the seven paradigm breakthroughs (reference frame, height datum, relativity, all-element effects, approximation methodology, the integrated reference system, and critical simplification)
Rigorous algorithmsThe dual system of spatial-domain integrals and spectral-domain SRBF with Analytical Compatibility as the hard constraint; the unified effect-treatment paradigm; collaborative approximation by multi-source heterogeneous observation systems
Independent softwarePAGravf4.5 (the “gravity field engine” of this theoretical system) and ETideLoad4.5 (the “deformation effect processor”), developed by code-level hybrid programming and with module-by-module open source codes
Validation and applicationThe five typical applications and the engineering validation in the theoretical papers; the accuracy and effect data published on the official site
The terms “gravity field engine” and “deformation effect processor” appear in Section 3, “support from an independent research platform”, of official page /h-nd-164.html.

12.2Engineering Validation: Which Propositions the Five Typical Applications Have Validated

Typical application (official title)Academic proposition validatedEffect as published on the official site
Seamless continuous monitoring of regional terrestrial water, ground deformation field and gravity field variationsThe five principles for deep fusion of multi-source heterogeneous data; collaborative monitoring of the load deformation field and the time-varying gravity field26 CORS stations, 8 gravity stations and 1 ground tilt station in and around the Three Gorges area, combined with hydrological, meteorological, satellite altimetry, Ziyuan-3 remote sensing and GRACE data, jointly determine the monthly grid time series of regional ground vertical deformation, ground gravity, ground tilt and groundwater variations; monitoring accuracy 5 mm for ground vertical deformation and 10 μGal for ground gravity variations
Assessment of ground stability variations and of geological hazard monitoring and early-warning capabilityThe quantitative criteria for ground stability degradation; the CORS network as a continuous deformation monitoring datumUsing data from 38 CORS stations and 39 meteorological stations in and around Lishui–Wenzhou, the monthly grid time series of 1′×1′ ground vertical deformation, ground gravity and ground stability are computed; the advance capture rate of geological hazard precursors reaches 92.5%
Refinement of the coastal-zone gravity field and geoidThe principle of regional (land-sea unified) refinement; remove-restore combining Local Terrain Effects with a reference gravity field2.5′×2.5′ land-sea unified ground gravity disturbances, vertical deflections, gravimetric quasi-geoid and sea surface topography of China are precisely determined; checked against more than 280 GNSS/leveling points, the root-mean-square error of the land-sea gravimetric quasi-geoid is 3.9 cm
Ground subsidence and height datum monitoring and maintenanceDynamic height datum maintenance; separation of the datum constant from its geometric realization; unification of the spatiotemporal datum of time-series InSAR and the CORS networkGround subsidence and regional height datum stability monitoring are carried out with the national GNSS reference station network and the CORS network; after unifying the spatiotemporal monitoring datum of time-series InSAR and CORS, atmospheric delays can be corrected and the vertical deformation effect of tidal loading compensated
Regional coordinated monitoring of geological hazards and numerical hazard predictionThe grid time series of ground stability variations and numerical hazard prediction; collaborative monitoring of groundwater and surface environmental load deformation fieldsWith 72 CORS stations, 44 groundwater monitoring stations and 41 hydrological stations in the Baoshan–Dali area, a grid time series model of regional ground stability variations and numerical hazard prediction at 1 km / 1 week is established; precursors appeared more than 2 days in advance at 186 of 197 hazard sites, an agreement rate of 94.4%; for the 90 events in 2020 the prediction rates at 1 week / two weeks / 1 month were 92.2% / 83.3% / 75.6% respectively
Titles are taken verbatim from the “Typical Applications” section of the official-site home page; the data and conclusions follow the official published wording.

12.3Overview of Academic Contributions

ContributionProblem addressedSignificance
Upgrade of the disciplinary positioning and the three philosophical tenetsBlurred disciplinary objects and task boundaries; missing criteria for elementsMakes the discipline a precise geodetic science with criteria and testability
The nine geodetic datum constants and their uniquenessDatums and parameters used interchangeably; conventions not made explicitProvides the criterion of “what may be conventionally defined / what must be measured”, supporting the integrated reference system
The “four-in-one” theoretical cornerstoneSeparate development of the reference frame, the height datum and relativityUnifies the three upon the Earth's gravity field and reshapes the foundational logic of the discipline
The gravity field-determined theory of the reference frameThe “conventionality” and “non-uniqueness” of the ITRSThe origin and z-axis of the reference frame are uniquely determined by geopotential coefficients
Theoretical reconstruction of the height datumThe orthometric height is non-unique, the true geoid is unmeasurable, and the quasi-geoid is difficult to express uniquelyW₀ becomes the unique invariant datum constant, and the Analytical Geoid and the Analytical Orthometric Height are introduced
Engineering of relativistic geodesyRelativity acts only as a higher-order correction and lacks engineering algorithmsThe 2PN metric and the spatiotemporal scales are turned into algorithms, supporting future atomic-clock measurement of height differences
The unified effect-treatment paradigmTerrain, tidal and load corrections are treated in isolation with inconsistent standardsAll geometric and physical elements share one unified, analytically compatible effect-treatment framework
Collaborative approximation theory for multi-source heterogeneous observation systemsClassical integral theory can hardly fuse multi-source space-air-land-sea dataObservation-system grouping, normal equation normalization and system weight optimization achieve the strongest data fusion
The integrated reference system for a deforming EarthCoordinate, height and gravity datums maintained separatelyProposes construction–realization–maintenance–updating schemes integrating coordinates, height, gravity and depth
Geodesy for a deforming Earth and “mathematical isomorphism”Deformation regarded as a correction term; time-variable theory lacks a framework of the same originTurns time-variable problems into solvable problems, allowing the steady-state approximation idea to migrate as a whole
The Spatial Representativeness Error and three accuracy schemesAccuracy concepts used interchangeably; quality control lacks a handleRewrites “point-value accuracy” as “resolution-dependent spatial average accuracy”, computable and verifiable
Critical inheritance and strategic simplificationThe spherical approximation, the complex Molodensky conceptual framework, the generalized use of terrain effectsStreamlines theory by “reducing unnecessary complexity” and reconstructs the boundary value problem classification

12.4Outlook: Three Lines the Official Site Points out as Still to Be Developed

DirectionOfficial-site basis
Continued tightening of the theoryOfficial page /h-nd-160 points out: “together with the subsequent unified theory of the geoidal potential and reference-frame spatiotemporal scales, it will form a complete theoretical foundation of the reference-frame gravity field”, indicating that this theoretical system is still being advanced
A new paradigm of spatiotemporal measurementOfficial page /h-nd-164, Section 2.3, points out that the relativistic algorithms lay the theoretical and algorithmic foundation for “the future use of optical atomic clocks to determine height differences directly and remotely, achieving unprecedented precision measurement unified in space and time”
Large-scale, intelligent and automated operationPrinciple 5 of the official fusion principles proposes “scientific support for the large-scale, intelligent and automated observation of the Earth”; the terrain effect and approximation algorithms are all linear and capable of error simulation, providing the conditions for large-scale quality control
Unifying the global height datumThe height datum theory section of the official site points out that the conceptual innovations “provide a clear scientific path towards unifying the global height datum in the future”
Each item in this section is quoted directly from the official published wording and represents the forward-looking directions given by the official site.

12.5Intended Readership Recommended by the Official Site

No.Audience (official wording)
1Researchers, experts and scholars, university teachers, graduate students and senior undergraduates in the fields of geodesy, surveying and mapping science and technology, geophysics, spatiotemporal information, space science and geodynamics
2Engineering technical experts and managers engaged in surveying and mapping engineering, satellite navigation, Earth observation, geological exploration, geo-environmental hazards and national defence surveying and mapping
Conclusion This body of academic thought can be summed up in one sentence: taking the Earth's gravity field as the core object, the three philosophical tenets as the criterion, and Analytical Compatibility and measurability as the bottom line, it rebuilds the theoretical foundation of geodesy; and then, through the “steady-state – time-variable” dual system, it turns that into a computing system that can be run, taught, recomputed and openly shared.
Its distinguishing feature lies not in the number of new terms, but in the fact that every new concept points to a concrete old problem and every new principle lands on a testable technical requirement — from the origin and axial direction of the reference frame, the height starting constant and the boundary value problem classification, to the two restrictive requirements for terrain effects and the definition of the Spatial Representativeness Error.

12.6Appendix: the Official Pages on Which This Report Is Based

PageAddressRole
Ideas & Philosophy section/h-col-105.htmlDisciplinary concepts, the metrological essence and normative constraints, geodetic datum constants, the “four-in-one” cornerstone, reference frames, height datums, regional refinement, terrain effects, boundary value problems, error analysis
Official page for Physical Geodesy/h-nd-164.htmlContent summary and four-part outline: disciplinary philosophy and paradigm innovation, the seven paradigm breakthroughs, support from an independent platform, and summary and intended readership
Official page for Geodesy for a Deforming Earth/h-nd-156.htmlThe concept of geodesy for a deforming Earth and series information
PAGravf4.5 function page/Geoid.htmlScientific objectives, the terrain effect algorithmic framework, characteristics of the integral algorithms, SRBF measures, algorithm testing and gravity exploration modeling
ETideLoad4.5 function page/Tide.htmlScientific objectives, technical features, principles of the load deformation field, the InSAR collaboration principle, the ground stability scheme, data formats and monitoring quantity conventions
Home page/Platform positioning and strategic transformation, the two systems, the technical foundation and scale, the example mechanism, the five typical applications
Downloads and Resources section/h-col-104.htmlProgram packages, User References, lists of algorithm and process documents, computation workflows and exercises, external resource links
Fortran Codes section/h-col-110.htmlModule-by-module open source codes and the elements of a module introduction; the basis of the lineage in Chapters 9 and 10 of this report
Teaching courseware pages/h-nd-166.html … /h-nd-173.htmlThe nine courseware decks (introduction and Chapters 1–8) and the description of each chapter
Theoretical and methodological article pages/h-nd-160, 161, 162, 163, 84, 87, 91, 82, 83, 23Reference-frame monitoring methods, height datum updating, error analysis and accuracy assessment, terrain effect principles and methods, level surface accuracy assessment, CORS network stability, system introduction, current state of solid Earth tide research, teaching software, coastal-zone refinement
Memorial and heritage article pages/h-nd-85, /h-nd-86The academic lineage and the thread of academic exchange
Academic and Technical Exchange section/h-nr.html (with pages and category pages)Article index and categories (News / Software Teaching / Work Processes / Source Codes)
Online exchange/h-msgBoard.htmlThe entry point for public discussion and open debate
All names and technical terms in this report follow the official wording; the theories, data and engineering conclusions stated here are quoted from publicly accessible official pages. The official sections and page lists are continuously updated, so please refer to the current state of the official site.